What is 1÷1π ? Is it (1÷1)π, is it 1÷(1π) or does it depend on the country?
The Huawei calculator in my phone gives π, and as Huawei is in China this might be a Chinese mathematical rule
The CALCU app in my phone gives 1÷π, and as CALCU is in the USA (as seen in the address of the app in Google Play) this might be an American mathematical rule
Do you know how it works in every country?
- KrishnamurthyLv 72 months ago
1 ÷ 1π = (1 ÷ 1)π = 3.141592...
1 ÷ 1π = 1 ÷ (1π) = 0.318309...
- PuzzlingLv 72 months ago
Unfortunately, it's ambiguous.
If you had written 1 ÷ 1 × π, then division and multiplication have the same precedence and you would perform them left to right.
(1 ÷ 1) × π
= 1 × π
But yours is written as 1÷1π
Here some people see an implicit grouping of 1π, much like when you have a coefficient in front of a variable (e.g. 4x) and they might interpret it as 1 ÷ (1π)
When your expression seems ambiguous like this, I would recommend adding parentheses to explicitly show your intended grouping, rather than relying on others to apply the desired precedence rules.
The rules of precedence say the answer should be just π. If I type that into WolframAlpha, that's exactly what I get. But as you have shown, some calculator programs can get it wrong. For that reason, always use parentheses is you are worried it will be interpreted incorrectly.
I tried the CALCU app and it does seem to add some implied grouping.
If I type 1 ÷ 1 × π, the answer is π, but if I type 1 ÷ 1π, it see it as 1/π.
- TomVLv 72 months ago
Per the accepted order of operations, PE(MD)(AS), 1÷1π is equivalent to (1÷1)π = π
1÷1π is 1 divided by 1 multiplied by π
Since multiplication and division are equal priority, they are performed in strict left to right order. Therefore the first operation is 1 divided by 1 = 1. The result is multiplied by π yielding a result of π.
- ZirpLv 72 months ago
one divided by 3.1415...
(1÷1)π would equal π
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- ?Lv 52 months ago
It depends upon the pie filling.
- billrussell42Lv 72 months ago
it is ambiguous, you have to add parans.
When in doubt, add the parans.