Anonymous
Anonymous asked in TravelIrelandOther - Ireland · 3 months ago

Why do some Irish people feel if you are not 75% or more then dont say you are Irish, or of you dont have red hair blue eyes and freckles? ?

Is that just kind of an ignorant American thinking? 

9 Answers

Relevance
  • 3 weeks ago

    Ireland is now full of blacks and Pakistanis, it is part of EU

  • Anonymous
    1 month ago

    Jus because surname McDonald McNamara McCormick McCarthy Kelly Brosnan Myers O'Mahoney   O'Sullivan O'Saughnessy Hennessy Fahy  Joyce  Balwin   De Courcy Tyan Walsh  Lawrence Noonan O'Brien Barry Cooney Coloney  McKenna O or Mc what whatever means son/daughter of doesn't mean part Irish nation or a member of our Gaelic clans all Irish surnames are Irish clans we the Irish people especially Roman Catholic population are descendants people ruled Ireland hundreds of years ago Gaelic nobility before English Protestants raped the women murder the men.

  • 2 months ago

    Irish Americans are American. This idea that you’re Irish despite being a 3/4/5 generation American 

    is a pile of crap.

  • Orla C
    Lv 7
    2 months ago

    We don't do percentages when it comes to nationality.

    The word Irish (and German and French and all the rest of them) has a different meaning in the US. It refers to your ancestry and heritage. When you say I'm Irish in the US, everyone assumes you are talking about that. Everyone around you is assumed to be of American nationality, so they get that this is what you're talking about, ancestry and heritage. 

    However, when you are talking to a European, Irish, German, French, etc. all refer to nationality and citizenship, and not really ancestry and heritage. Therefore, to someone who grew up in Europe, you are American, not Irish or German or French or Italian. American is your nationality, not Irish or Italian or whatever. This is why you cannot call yourself any one of these things in Europe ... and you'll hear about it if you try. But you CAN say that you are an American with Irish ancestry (or German or French or any of the others) and this would be perfectly correct. 

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ?
    Lv 4
    2 months ago

    Nigerians and Pakistanis are spreading all over Ireland

    Source(s): Irish
  • Anonymous
    2 months ago

    I'm Irish. Of course being Irish is about the blood in your veins, but it's also about who you are. Yanks come to Ireland and say "I'm Irish! My mother's grandmother was from Cork! My name's Tommy O'Sullivan! I'm one of you!" And it's just straight bollocks. If you weren't raised here, you're not Irish. You're Irish-American. It doesn't matter if you're one hundred percent Irish in terms of ancestry. We've got national heroes who were half Irish, but lived here, they were familiar with the culture. If my gran had been born in Walla Walla instead of Waterford could I claim to be American? Get over yourselves. It's not our fault you're looking to identify with something. What's lacking in your own life that you're compelled to seek that kind of validation from strangers? There's nothing wrong with being Irish-American. It's a lovely culture. But it's not OUR culture. Many places in the world welcomed us Irish and we thrived. We're grateful for that. But quit trying to elbow your way in to our culture. If a baby born to an Irish ma and an Irish da were to be adopted on the day of his or her birth and raised in fecking Lithuania for 25 years and returned would that young lad or lass be Irish or Lithuanian? Boyo, the Pakistanis and Somalis I play footy with in the park at the weekend would be more Irish. It's not a numbers game and never has been. 

  • 3 months ago

    Because theyre nationalist idiots. My dad is irish, my mother is from nz and i was born in london. I moved here when i was 2 years old yet people tell me im not irish. What else would i be? English? I know nothing of england. I know ireland, its my home.

  • Zirp
    Lv 7
    3 months ago

    I guess they are infected with racism

    For most ethnicities, LANGUAGE is the main criterion.

    If you don't speak the language you are not part of the ethnicity

    But then Irish aka Gaeilge was almost eradicated by the English

  • 3 months ago

    Lol no real Irish person goes by that percentage shite. That's what Plastic Paddies do. Who usually are stupid Yanks, who seem to have no real grasp on what what being Irish actually is. 

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.