When a sentence begins with two prepositional phrases joined by the word and, where should the writer place a comma ?
high school practical English
- busterwasmycatLv 72 months ago
Mostly it depends on how it is to be said. Is the double prepositional phrase given as a unity, a single combined statement, or is the second phrase a type of aside (parenthetical comment) that simply happens to be located after a different but unlinked first one? Typically, the use of "and" serves to declare the second as equal to and inseparable from the first and thus the comma ought to follow the second phrase only. However, there are ways to construct a sentence where that general idea is not true.
- geezerLv 72 months ago
If the two phrases are at the start of a longer sentence then the commar goes after the second phrase.
For example ..
''Through rain that poured like a waterfall and winds that howled like the devil, the ship battled it's way through the storm''.
There are some people who would add a second commar before the ''and''.
''Through rain that poured like a waterfall, and winds that howled like the devil, the ship battled it's way through the storm''.
It's not 'wrong' as such .. it's just 'too much punctuation'.
- lenpol7Lv 72 months ago
Always before the conjunction , 'and' in this case.
- Lib.rare.ianLv 72 months ago
"Over the river and through the woods, to Grandmother's house we go."
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Bill BLv 62 months ago
The comma should be placed after the second one.