Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Society & CultureReligion & Spirituality · 4 weeks ago

Atheists, if God doesn't exist then how can 3 = 0? How can that be true without the magic of God?

If we start with

x^2+x+1 = 0 (<=> x+1 = -x^2)

since x can't be 0, we can divide by x

x+1+1/x = 0

substitute x+1 for -x^2

-x^2 + 1/x = 0

1/x = x^2

1 = x^3

x=1

put solution x = 1 it into the original equation x^2+x+1 = 0

1^2+1+1 = 0 or 3 = 0. So, obviously 3 = 0. But how do you explain this fact without God and His powers, atheists?

Update:

Jeremy: You are being DISHONEST. You just picked 5 arbitrarily.

I started with the equation x^2+x+1=0 and moving over the x^2 term gives x+1 = -x^2, so x+1+1/x = -x^2 + 1/x = 0 is true of the equation which I started with for the value of x which solves x^2+x+1 = 0 and is a legal substitution because I was keeping the equation still equal to 0, so it still corresponds to the x that solves the equation, not any random x whatsoever, such as the irrelevant 5, which you just pulled out of your a$$

Update 2:

And I wasn't saying that x+1= -x^2 for all values of x. I was clearly working with a special case. I was having the equation equal 0, where that was equivalent to x+1=-x^2

And btw -x^2 for 5 isn't (-5)^2=25, but -(5^2)=-25

15 Answers

Relevance
  • 4 weeks ago

    This equation isn't even solvable. And your math makes absolutely no sense. Here is your equation graphed. Zoomed in so you can see that the line never shows a possible y value of zero.

    Attachment image
  • 4 weeks ago

    well don't

    now we know you are stupid as well as unqualified

  • 4 weeks ago

    I'm pretty sure x=-1. No?

  • Yoda
    Lv 6
    4 weeks ago

    0 = matter + gravity

    Matter = positive energy

    Gravity = negative energy

    Thus, according to quantum physics, it is possible (via quantum tunnelling) for the universe to come from empty space (where empty space-time is just quantum fields).

    It's explained by some people who are less ignorant than me on the topic here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8-oocxPwlM

    Youtube thumbnail

    • Yoda
      Lv 6
      4 weeks agoReport

      Arvin Ash understands enough to transmit a coherent message---I'm actually going to watch this over a few times before I attempt to explain it to myself

      How particles get mass: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joTKd5j3mzk

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • poldi2
    Lv 7
    4 weeks ago

    Your math is nonsense, but you are free to think whatever you like.

  • Jeremy
    Lv 6
    4 weeks ago

    "substitute x+1 for -x^2" NOPE

    5+1 = 6

    (-5)^2=25

    I mean, there are more errors in your math than simply that one. But it boils down to you're substituting values out of the original equation with no justification, solving a second completely new equation, and then saying 3=0. And, this proves your God, how exactly?Edit:  Yes, I picked 5 arbitrarily.  Prefer I do this systematically?  1-100.

    1+1=2

    (-1)^2=1

    2+1=3

    (-2)^2=4

    3+1=4

    (-3)^2=9

    4+1=5

    (-4)^2=16

    5+1=6

    (-5)^2=25

    6+1=7

    (-6)^2=36

    7+1=8

    (-7)^2=49

    8+1=9

    (-8)^2=64

    9+1=10

    (-9)^2=81

    10+1=11

    (-10)^2=100

    11+1=12

    (-11)^2=121

    12+1=13

    (-12)^2=144

    13+1=14

    (-13)^2=169

    14+1=15

    (-14)^2=196

    15+1=16

    (-15)^2=225

    16+1=17

    (-16)^2=256

    17+1=18

    (-17)^2=289

    18+1=19

    (-18)^2=324

    19+1=20

    (-19)^2=361

    20+1=21

    (-20)^2=400

    21+1=22

    (-21)^2=441

    22+1=23

    (-22)^2=484

    23+1=24

    (-23)^2=529

    24+1=25

    (-24)^2=576

    25+1=26

    (-25)^2=625

    26+1=27

    (-26)^2=676

    27+1=28

    (-27)^2=729

    28+1=29

    (-28)^2=784

    29+1=30

    (-29)^2=841

    30+1=31

    (-30)^2=900

    31+1=32

    (-31)^2=961

    32+1=33

    (-32)^2=1024

    33+1=34

    (-33)^2=1089

    34+1=35

    (-34)^2=1156

    35+1=36

    (-35)^2=1225

    36+1=37

    (-36)^2=1296

    37+1=38

    (-37)^2=1369

    38+1=39

    (-38)^2=1444

    39+1=40

    (-39)^2=1521

    40+1=41

    (-40)^2=1600

    41+1=42

    (-41)^2=1681

    42+1=43

    (-42)^2=1764

    43+1=44

    (-43)^2=1849

    44+1=45

    (-44)^2=1936

    45+1=46

    (-45)^2=2025

    46+1=47

    (-46)^2=2116

    47+1=48

    (-47)^2=2209

    48+1=49

    (-48)^2=2304

    49+1=50

    (-49)^2=2401

    50+1=51

    (-50)^2=2500

    51+1=52

    (-51)^2=2601

    52+1=53

    (-52)^2=2704

    53+1=54

    (-53)^2=2809

    54+1=55

    (-54)^2=2916

    55+1=56

    (-55)^2=3025

    56+1=57

    (-56)^2=3136

    57+1=58

    (-57)^2=3249

    58+1=59

    (-58)^2=3364

    59+1=60

    (-59)^2=3481

    60+1=61

    (-60)^2=3600

    61+1=62

    (-61)^2=3721

    62+1=63

    (-62)^2=3844

    63+1=64

    (-63)^2=3969

    64+1=65

    (-64)^2=4096

    65+1=66

    (-65)^2=4225

    66+1=67

    (-66)^2=4356

    67+1=68

    (-67)^2=4489

    68+1=69

    (-68)^2=4624

    69+1=70

    (-69)^2=4761

    70+1=71

    (-70)^2=4900

    71+1=72

    (-71)^2=5041

    72+1=73

    (-72)^2=5184

    73+1=74

    (-73)^2=5329

    74+1=75

    (-74)^2=5476

    75+1=76

    (-75)^2=5625

    76+1=77

    (-76)^2=5776

    77+1=78

    (-77)^2=5929

    78+1=79

    (-78)^2=6084

    79+1=80

    (-79)^2=6241

    80+1=81

    (-80)^2=6400

    81+1=82

    (-81)^2=6561

    82+1=83

    (-82)^2=6724

    83+1=84

    (-83)^2=6889

    84+1=85

    (-84)^2=7056

    85+1=86

    (-85)^2=7225

    86+1=87

    (-86)^2=7396

    87+1=88

    (-87)^2=7569

    88+1=89

    (-88)^2=7744

    89+1=90

    (-89)^2=7921

    90+1=91

    (-90)^2=8100

    91+1=92

    (-91)^2=8281

    92+1=93

    (-92)^2=8464

    93+1=94

    (-93)^2=8649

    94+1=95

    (-94)^2=8836

    95+1=96

    (-95)^2=9025

    96+1=97

    (-96)^2=9216

    97+1=98

    (-97)^2=9409

    98+1=99

    (-98)^2=9604

    99+1=100

    (-99)^2=9801

    100+1=101

    (-100)^2=10000

    Appears your substitution is invalid for all positive integers.  Need me to repeat for negative (Spoilers: Your equation doesn't work there either).

    • jon pike
      Lv 7
      4 weeks agoReport

      That's kinda what I thought. If you're solving for x, why do you deem x=1 to begin with?

  • Mack
    Lv 7
    4 weeks ago

    You being bad at math is no reason to believe in deities....

  • 4 weeks ago

    One day trolls will be dragged from their holes And impaled.

    ~

  • 4 weeks ago

    Mayans used zero as a base number . How come Mayans know more about the cosmos than flat earth creationist ?

    Source(s): Their god makes your god look imaginary
  • 4 weeks ago

    I once pooped in the forest and 3 months later, I found cantaloupe vine

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.