🤦♂️Jeez, I hate questions like this. Partyline hackery. The economy is far more complicated then your liberal vs conservative narrative and one has to take into account wall street vs labor, unemployment rate vs income levels, I could go on.
Even what you pointed out in Massachusetts tells me little to nothing. What jobs were added, what income levels were they? What regions in Massachusetts are these jobs located at, is it skilled labor, unskilled labor, jobs requiring college degrees
See what I can tell about simplistic partyline hack questions like this is that the question poster doesn’t give a damn about the state of the economy, but instead simply playing a game of tribal politics, using the economy as stats like your talking about your favorite football team