You'd have to know whether it's covered, and you'd have to know the cost. If it's $750 and you have to meet the deductible first, then both plans would be exactly the same. But, just saying what the deductible is doesn't help. One would presume outpatient, of course, but there could be a cost difference between in hospital and in a surgical center. One way might be subject to a deductible, and the other might be a copay without having to meet the deductible.
In other words, nobody here could possibly know with the amount of information you've give. We can only tell you where to look - cost per pay, what circumstances does the deductible have to be met first, how the plans work for surgeries, etc...