What story concepts or short stories have been expanded on by different authors/writer?
the original thinker of the story did NOT write the story at all but juggled vague concepts.
eventually the ideas become novels, sagas, or scripts.
- 1 year agoFavorite Answer
If you're asking because you've thought of a brilliant idea for a story and want someone else to write it, I'm afraid it doesn't work like that.
An idea for a story, by itself, has no commercial value. For someone to write a story that they didn't think of, the idea has to be associated with something else that does have commercial value. Usually that's either the name of a famous person or a large enough amount of money to justify the time that the writer will spend writing the story. If you don't have either of those, your only other option is to learn to write well enough that you can write the story yourself.
- Elaine MLv 71 year ago
The Cthulhu mythos has had multiple writers expanding the storyline.
The shared universe books do the same thing.
- pianomanLv 71 year ago
Do you really expect someone to know the answer to that question? Think about it.
- Zac ZLv 71 year ago
You are asking about two different things in your original question and the clarification in your "Update 1".
An example that fits the criteria for your original question would be "Nightfall" by Isaac Asimov. This short story was expanded into a novel of the same name by Robert Silverberg.
Silverberg also expanded another of Asimov's stories, "The Bicentennial Man", into the novel "The Positronic Man" but I'm not sure whether Asimov was involved in the expansion. The novel was published in October 1992, half a year after Asimov died of AIDS (after having contracted HIV from a blood transfusion during a bypass surgery). In light of this timing, I conjecture that Asimov had little to know input in the expansion.
Another example, to a limited content is "Child of an Ancient City", which was written as a short story by Tad Williams and then expanded by Nina Kiriki Hoffman into a novel, albeit with Williams's involvement. Reportedly, Hoffman wrote the manuscript for the novel since Williams didn't have time to do that himself being in the middle of writing his "Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn" trilogy. Williams then edited it into its final form together with Hoffman.
I've also seen it many times in movies that the credits read something like "Screenplay by ABC, based on an idea by XYZ" but I can't give you an example right now.
All of these would not qualify as examples for what you ask for in your "Update 1".
Actually, the idea-to-screenplay examples look like they would qualify for both but in your original question you talk of "different authors/writers" implying that the original story was also produced by a writer which is incompatible with what you ask in your "Update 1".
Candidates for the second variety might be folk tales, fairy tales, legends, etc. that were put in writing at some point in time. The question would of course be whether there really was one original thinker and it will be impossible in many cases to know how vague their original concepts were.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- bluebellbkkLv 71 year ago
But how could you possibly know?