My son's car was a total loss, what can he say for a better offer?
My son got a deal on his car, because he knew a friend. He paid 1650 for the car he has, but the car is normally sold at lowest about $2500. He was given an estimate for his car, but its not enough to purchase the same car or another one in the area we live in. How can he negotiate for a better offer?
- oklatomLv 75 months ago
Insurance will give him fair market value for the car before the accident. That is the end of it.
- Jay PLv 75 months ago
Did your son fix anything or purchase anything on the vehicle while he owned it? You can use those receipts to say there was additional money put into this vehicle recently which would increase its value.
I had a co-worker that had a vehicle that was written off. He had just replaced the transmission a few months earlier so he submitted those receipts to his insurance company and it increased the value of the vehicle significantly.
- AlCaponeLv 75 months ago
If you can find and print out ads, pictures, prices for the same or similar cars, same age, similar mileage, similar condition -- and higher prices -- in your area and present them to the insurance company, you *might* have a chance of getting a better offer. Using Kelley Blue Book and other online pricing sources does no good because the insurance company can easily argue that the prices are not representative of prices in your area. Only actual ads or sale prices from your area are going to have a chance for you. And get a handful of those ads, not just one or two.
- regeruggedLv 75 months ago
Go to Kelley Blue Book, www.kbb.com. Input all of the info on your vehicle. Get a retail price. Add sales tax and title transfer charges. The site will also find similar cars available for sale.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- PercyqtedLv 75 months ago
If he can find similar examples of his car for sale at a higher price than he's offered he may be able to reject the offer once. But no more than once.
- EvaLv 45 months ago
Pictures to show it's condition before the accident, research it's value on resale sites, Edmunds, or Kelly Blue Book. Remember that his deductible will come off whatever value they determine, so he's not going to get the full value anyway.
- KazLv 65 months ago
He can't get any more than what the insurance company thinks is fair market value is for a car in fair condition. It really doesn't matter what he paid for it, if he paid $ 5K for it, and its FMV is $2500, he'll only get the FMV. You could argue with the insurance company that maybe it was in great condition, or had some valuable add on (special equipment) or very low mileage - they'll "might" adjust the payment a few hundred dollars.
- jimanddottaylorLv 75 months ago
When you apply for insurance, they ask you what you paid for the car. If he got a great deal, that is the maximum they will go.......unless you can argue that the car appreciated in value.
They have the money and he is walking. Not an even bargaining table.
- .Lv 75 months ago
Back in 2008, I was rear-ended about 300 miles from my home causing 9,200 dollars damage to my Nissan Titan. The insurance company said they would pay for a rental while my truck was getting fixed, but it had to be a subcompact. Once I mentioned getting a lawyer, they quickly said I could get a full-size pickup.
Lawyers sometimes can fix problems.
- Anonymous5 months ago
He has to find examples of similar cars for sale. The closer these cars are to his vehicle the more likely his insurer will cave in. They always start low as it's a business matter. He will have to put the research in to get the offer raised.