Did anyone else ever think that whenever Luke from Gilmore Girls / A day in the life smiled and laughed always seemed so fake?

Don't get me wrong , I love both these versions of the show. Gilmore Girls is easily in my top 5 favorite shows of all time. It's just that whenever Luke was smiling or laughing I couldn't get into it. He is always such a hard *** grump that his smiles and laugh never seemed genuine like it was a lie.
Update: I am also talking about in the original series too
1 answer 1