I'm not a female, but as a guy, I think Jeff Hardy is better looking, honestly. Drew McIntyre def' has the superstar look though. Jeff Hardy had/has a unique look. He is handsome and was never overly muscular, and he didn't need to be, because it worked for him. females loved him, and when he took off his shirt.
BQ: Well, I would judge based off of their workrate in the ring, and who has more stamina.