Guiding Light fans: Eve Guthrie and Ed Bauer vs. Annie Dutton and Alan Spaulding. Which was the better couple?

Ed/Eve and Annie/Alan were both popular couples on Guiding Light. Similarities: 1.) Both involved a woman in need of emotional support. 2.) Both were nearly destroyed by their obsessions with other guys, Eve with Nick, Annie with Josh. 3.) Ed and Alan both attempted to help Eve and Annie get their lives back on... show more Ed/Eve and Annie/Alan were both popular couples on Guiding Light.

Similarities:

1.) Both involved a woman in need of emotional support.

2.) Both were nearly destroyed by their obsessions with other guys, Eve with Nick, Annie with Josh.

3.) Ed and Alan both attempted to help Eve and Annie get their lives back on track.

4.) Both relationships featured a middle-aged man and a younger woman.

5.) Both got engaged only for neither marriage to come to fruition. Ed/Eve due to illness, Annie/Alan due to Annie's marriage to another man.

I thought both couples were great, but I liked Ed/Eve better because Ed had more of a positive impact on Eve.

Which do you believe was the better couple?
3 answers 3