No, not in cricket. It is not just about pumping your fist and yelling, "C'mon guys, let's do this!" Charismatic cricketers rarely make good captains because they are all about themselves.
Cricket captains have a LOT to think about in a game, like rotating the bowlers suitably, setting fielders, judging conditions and match tactics. The best team captains in cricket are usually the most tactically aware and experienced players, so they will be often be one of the "senior" players in a team. The best batsman or bowler in a team will rarely also be an ideal captain until he has had at least 10 years experience.