Do race and ethnicity really have no DNAs and genetic bases in biology?

5 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 year ago
    Favorite Answer

    Humans originated in Africa, and all non-Africans are descendants of a small number of Africans who migrated out of Africa 60,000-70.000 years ago. Many of these people still look very much like Africans because they changed little since they migrated out of Africa, because their ancestors ended up in places with similar climates as Africa, such as New Guinea, SE Asia, Papua and Australia

    Europeans, and NE Asians, OTOH, have changed because they adapted to cold climates by evolving straight hair, lighter skin tones, shorter arms and legs, more rounded torso, taller and narrower nose bridges, thinner lips, more facial and body hair, and more fat under the skin. The Europeans and NE Asians (China, Japan and Korea) descended from Africans who stayed in Central Asia for about 20,000 years before migrating again. Central Asia is cooler than Africa, so some of these adaptations to cold climates first evolved in Central Asians. Europeans and NE Asians therefore are similar because they inherited some features from their shared C. Asian ancestors. and they then evolved similar features independently by adapting to cold climates of the last ice age. .

    Further, humans have not stopped migrating since then, and we have NE Asians migrating south to interbreed with SE Asians and their descendants have a mix of cold and warm adapted traits and a mix of genes. Central Asians and Europeans too have migrated to parts of East Asia. Europeans also migrated to the Middle East and North Africa, and later some of the Middle East people migrated back to Europe and to North Africa. For example, Italians from the southern part of their country are more closely related to people from Turkey, Iraq and Iran then they are to the northern Italians, who are more closely related to western Europeans like Germans, British and French. Because of such mixing it is difficult to find genes or traits that can be used to identify the people from one region vs. another. What we do have are mitochondrial DNA and Y chromosome markers that can trace a person's ancestor to a particular region, but these markers cannot be used to define races, since they do not produce the raical characteristics thaqt people notice.

    Because scientists cannot come up with any good way to divide the human species into different subspecies or races, they have stopped trying.

  • Zirp
    Lv 7
    1 year ago

    Your ethnicity is the language and culture you were raised in. It has nothing to do with genetics.

    Races of domesticated animals do exist, and are the result of dozens of generations worth of purposebreeding and inbreeding. Humans are so similar genetically (thanks to one or more near-extinctions) that they cannot be categorised into races in any way that makes sense (unless it is: amerindians, australian aborigines, and every body else) . Every human has 47 independently passed on bundles of DNA, and the luck of the draw decides which 23 chromosomes of his/hers are passed on to a child (s)he makes. Sometimes two homologous chromosomes even exchange parts before one of the two gets passed on.

  • MARK
    Lv 7
    1 year ago

    Race and ethnicity, especially in how society uses these terms, has no basis in biology. The terms are used as socio-cultural constructs and often, particularly race, in a negative way.

    That does not mean there are not populations of humans that have unique genetic characteristics; there are. However, these do not match with race as often defined such as Caucasian, *****, etc.

  • Anonymous
    1 year ago

    Of course race is genetic. And that's all it is: genetic.

    • MARK
      Lv 7
      1 year agoReport

      Race has no basis in biology.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 year ago

    I think that people shouldn't ask negatively phrased questions.

    Anyway, race definitely has genetic components which is why traditionally Finnish aren't giving birth to African pygmies and vice versa.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.