Urban Decay Perversion, and Too Cool for School Dinoplatz Escalator are my picks. Too Faced Better than Sex is about as good. I don't care for Benefit's mascara formulas.
I always feel the need to add that mascara recommendations are the hardest, because while everyone likes a good lipstick or concealer formula, lashes vary so much that a great formula for my short, thick, moderately full, and wild growing lashes might be terrible if your lashes are long, thin, sparse, and evenly spaced. It may work better to find a person with lashes like your own, then ask them specifically what they like.