What do you think about pocket pistols for self defense?
I don't have the money, and don't want to be uncomfortable carrying around a bulky gun and having to change my wardrobe.
Are pocket pistols a viable option in self defense? I don't necessarily want to be told that its better than nothing, because what that tells me is that I'm basically throwing rocks instead of stopping the attacker.
I want something lethal, are .22 bullets not anywhere as lethal as a 9mm?
If not should I get a snub .38?
- Russ in NOVALv 72 years agoBest Answer
If you plan to use any handgun for self defense, take a basic handgun course before you purchase your handgun. That will answer many of the basic questions you have. After you get comfortable with your handgun in the range take a personal defense course, because ultimately, how you react in the time of crisis will dictate how effective your handgun is. You can have the most powerful handgun in the world (one that might even "blow your head clean off"), but it is useless unless you can hit your target in a life or death situation.
You need to stop thinking about "lethality" and think about the "stopping" an attack. .22LR (according to some articles) kills more people than any other caliber in the US. The problem is that death is often by bleeding out or some other slow factor and can take minutes. It doesn't stop a determined attacker. .22LR has poor penetration and small would channel.
In addition to snub nose revolvers, pocket pistols tend to range from .32 ACP to .380 ACP. Most compact 9mm Luger and higher power cartridge pistols are a little too big for your average pocket. Even in your pocket, you must have a holster that covers the trigger for safety for any handgun. Many negligent discharges, some resulting in fatalities occur from improperly carried firearms. You may think shooting yourself in the leg may be non-lethal, but hit your femoral artery and you will likely bleed out before EMTs can get to you.
I have an instructor who carried .32 ACP Kel-Tec because it was so easy to keep in the pocket and he felt with his training and proficiency, he could put every round on target. Personally, I often carry a .380 ACP in the summer with shorts, etc. In the winter I more often carry 9mm Luger or .45 ACP. .380 ACP is a marginal round. If you use an expanding bullet, it may not penetrate optimally. When I carry the .380 ACP (or whatever I am carrying), I generally take it to the range and train more than just slow fire at a stationary target to minimize ME as the reason for a failure to stop.
I prefer the semi-auto .380 over .snub nose .38 special +P because it is easier to conceal and faster to reload and for whatever reason, I can shoot more accurately. A .38 special +P load with a 158 gr LSWCHP bullet will probably beat anything available for .380 acp, in terms of wound channel size and penetration.
- 2 years ago
- John de WittLv 72 years ago
You should understand that you're going to have to buy a holster for the purpose anyway, even though you're putting it in your pocket. There are holsters designed for the purpose. A 38 Special snubby can be inexpensive, but it will not be comfortable. Something like the Sig P365 would be appropriate but it probably going to be somewhere north of $500.
- BBeanLv 72 years ago
I think it is OK. I have carried a Seecamp .32 since 1991. It`s in my pocket now so how could I advise differently?
I carry a Kahr CW.45 on my belt as back-up when I leave the house.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- brettLv 62 years ago
The Kel-Tec PF9 is an inexpensive, small weapon that shoots a rather under-powered 9mm bullet. However, loading it with a couple rounds of hollow point for effect, followed by FMJ ball ammo for penetration would be an inexpensive and effective personal defense system. There are also several pocket sized weapons in .45 that are now available. The .357 Sig round is an interesting cartridge that is available in highly concealable pistols. The Ladysmith or Chief's Special revolver loaded with +P ammo is always a good choice though, and you can't beat the reliability of a revolver when it absolutely, positively has to go bang.
- Anonymous2 years ago
I'm sorry you live in a country where guns are freely allowed, of course someone could take it off you and shoot you with it even if they don't have a gun.