Luke asked in SportsFootball (American) · 3 years ago

Best NFL Player of all time at each position? (I have mine, I just want to see other peoples)?

My List

G.O.A.T.

Peyton Manning

Offense

Qb: Peyton Manning

RB: Walter Payton

FB: Jim Brown

Wr1: Jerry Rice (duh)

Wr2: Randy Moss

TE: Tony Gonzales (could be Gronk soon)

T: Anthony Muñoz

G: Larry Allen

C: Mike Webster

G: Kohn Hannah

T: Bruce Matthews

Defense

DE: Deacon Jones

DT: Bob Lilly

DT: Alan Page

DE: Bruce Smith

OLB: Lawrence Taylor

MLB: Ray Lewis

MLB: Dick Butkus

OLB: Derrick Brooks (flame me all you want he was a playmaker)

CB: Deion Sanders (too lethal to leave out)

CB: Night Train Lane

FS: Ed Reed

SS: Ronnie Lott

Special Teams

K: George Blanda (because qb ability)

P: Ray Guy (because punting and qb ability)

Returner: Devin Hester (this shouldn't be questioned)

3 Answers

Relevance
  • Alice
    Lv 6
    3 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Tom Brady is the G.O.A.T. (duh)

    Manning was simply a no-huddle offense stat padder who always had insane talent at WR and had rules recreated in his favor because of Bill Polian.

    Offense

    QB: Tom Brady (only QB to ever throw 4,000yds without a 1k receiver and he did it twice. He has the most TD's to different receivers of anyone by far, most wins, won with multiple OC's(Manning had Tom Moore most of his career), the only unanimous MVP ever(Manning shared one with McNair). )

    RB: Walter Payton

    FB: Since FB is a dead position I'll instead include a slot receiver; Steve Largent

    WR1: Jerry Rice

    WR2: Randy Moss

    TE: Gronk holds the title for most TD's by a TE, so Gronk.

    T: Anthony Muñoz

    RG: Will Shields

    C: Mike Webster

    LG: John Hannah

    LT: Orlando Pace

    Defense

    DE: Reggie White

    DT: Bob Lilly

    DT: Alan Page

    DE: Bruce Smith

    OLB: Andre Tippett(surrounded by a vastly inferior defense and had comparable numbers to LT)

    MLB: Ray Lewis

    MLB: Zach Thomas (huuugely underrated, probably the best late round draft pick after Brady)

    OLB: Derrick Brooks (I agree, historically he was one of the most dominant LB's ever)

    CB: Champ Bailey

    CB: Mike Haynes (Lane and Tatum were just dirty players)

    FS: Ed Reed

    SS: Ronnie Lott

    Special Teams

    K: Vanderjagt by the numbers, probably Vinatieri though.

    P: Ray Guy

    KR: Devin Hester (Donte Hall deserves mentioning)

    • Luke3 years agoReport

      Oh forgot to add when you say Tatum do you mean Jack Tatum (The assassin best nickname ever) cuz h was a free safety and for TE though Gronk can block he was not as good as Gonzales in terms of blocking and I think about the block ability in TEs

  • 3 years ago

    You have 12 players on defense.

    • Luke3 years agoReport

      Yeah it was 3-4 and 4-3 included

  • Jeremy
    Lv 5
    3 years ago

    whoa..whoa....how can you have Peyton Manning at #1 when Brady has won more games and more super bowls?

    • Luke3 years agoReport

      Can't answer the question how asked and are just in these boards to argue, y'all need to understand not everybody agrees with your opinion so as people will respect yours respect others

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.