關於the most 與the best

今天做題目遇到一題

Among all the committee members,Mr. Smith is ______ one for employees'

rights and benefits.

A.more support

B.the best support

C.the most supportive

D.more supportive

問題1.沒記錯的話the best 與the most都是最高級且用於3者以上

答案是C,B不能選的原因是?是否把support改成supportive變成形容詞就可?

那是這樣的話,也就是說the best 與the most後面要先接形容詞是嗎?

問題2.怕自己認知錯誤,可否說明一下the best 與the most的不同

Update:

我整理一下

印象中會用到the most是看形容詞是否3音節以上,不然就在形容詞後面加est

那是否可以這樣說,出現比較級最高級the most與 the xxxest時就是代表量

the best就是代表質,假使選項出現這兩種且寫法都是正確的,就依照句子的意思去判斷呢?

但是DaSaGwa大師你舉的例子

Among the committee members, employee members are the best supportive group for employees' rights and benefits.

我看不太出來這句哪邊是代表質了

3 Answers

Rating
  • Beth
    Lv 7
    5 years ago
    Best Answer

    我直接回答 the most 和 the best 的不同.

    ----

    先複習一下:

    有的形容詞比較級是在前面加上 more, 最高級是在前面加上 most.

    有的形容詞比較級是在後面加上 -er, 最高級是在前面加上 -est. 如: richer, richest.

    有的形容詞比較級和最高級是不同字. 如 good(well) / better / best

    ----

    (1) Among all the committee members, Mr. Smith is the most supportive one for employees' rights and benefits.

    在這個句子裡, the most supportive 是 supportive 的最高級.

    我把句子改寫簡單一點, 讓你比較一下這三句:

    (2) Among all the students, John is the tallest one.

    (3) Among all the students, Mary is the most beautiful one.

    你會發現(1), (2), (3)其實是一樣的結構. 只是因為形容詞不同, 所以最高級的型態不同.

    再來, 從簡單的開始, 在(3)中, 如果我們把 the most beautiful 換成 the best beautiful one 會變怎樣呢?

    (4) Among all the students, Mary is the best beautiful one.

    先不管這個句子有沒有意義, 我特意將 beautiful one 標示成同一個顏色, 就是要讓你看出, 此時 best 這個字修飾的是 beautiful one 而不是beautiful.

    換上一個有意義的句子:

    (5) The best supportive bras have an inner support triangle that positions and supports the breast.

    (6) Clinical studies are being conducted without a clear definition of the best supportive care provided in the comparator arms of trials.

    (7) The best supportive role that most adults can play is simply as a source of encouragement.

    所以在這個題目中, 就算(B)這個選項改成the best supportive還是不能選, 原因是因為句意不對.

    最後, 講一點關於the best 和 the most的相同, 就是the best 有一些慣用說法可以取代 the most 或是和 the most意思很接近. 我想這可能是你會混淆的原因.

    If you like something best or like it the best, you prefer it.

    ex: The thing I liked best about the show was the music.If you say that a particular person knows best, you mean that they have a lot of experience and should therefore be trusted to make decisions for other people.

    ex: He was convinced that doctors and dentists knew best.

    2014-09-12 00:25:24 補充:

    我也不太理解為什麼要去質或是量來去區分該用什麼, 這好像把問題複雜化了. the best除了我講的兩種習慣用法之外, 都是當成 good/well 的最高級, 如果你用good/well 解釋不通, 就代表不能用the best.

    2014-09-12 00:27:55 補充:

    She is the most beautiful girl in her class. 你要說的是她是最漂亮(the most beautiful girl), 並不是要說她是最好的(the best girl), 所以當然是要用 the most. 應該沒有the best的問題.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    這家不錯 lv333。cC買幾次啦真的一樣

    力亹

  • 5 years ago

    B不能選的原因是?是否把support改成supportive變成形容詞就可?

    Yes, you are right, but they don't have the same meaning!

    也就是說the best 與the most後面要先接形容詞是嗎?

    Not really, they can be followed with noun. For example, the best actor, for the most part, ...

    可否說明一下the best 與the most的不同

    The major difference between "the best" and "the most" is:

    "the best" talks about quality (質量)

    "the most" talks about quantity (數量)

    In your questioned sentence, it talks about "quantity", not "quality", because of "Among all the committee members"

    2014-09-11 06:39:25 補充:

    Since Beth has taken the route of comparative and superlative case for comparison, I like talk about this in my point of view:

    "best" is the superlative of "good"

    "most" is the superlative of "many or much".

    2014-09-11 06:43:06 補充:

    Let's not go into the application of these two words (best; most) or even the superlative, but just look at where they come from (good; many or much).

    2014-09-11 06:45:23 補充:

    Let me give some examples for using 'good".

    He is a good man.

    She has done a good job.

    This is a good choice.

    These sentences use "good" to describe the characteristic (quality).

    2014-09-11 06:48:20 補充:

    How about "many or much"?

    How much does it cost?

    How many of them will come?

    He has many brothers and sisters.

    She has drunk too much wine.

    These sentences use "much or many" to describe quantity.

    2014-09-11 06:54:43 補充:

    By the way, do you know "quality" and "quantity" are antonyms (反義詞) to each other. It means their meaning is opposite.

    The above saying is why I say, "the difference between best and most is quality and quantity (質和量的區別)"

    2014-09-11 07:00:00 補充:

    As far as using "the best" in this sentence, if you write it as:

    Among the committee members, employee members are _the best supportive group_ for employees' rights and benefits.

    2014-09-11 07:00:40 補充:

    In the above sentence, it is talking about the quality of committee members, not the quantity.

    2014-09-12 02:37:10 補充:

    我看不太出來這句哪邊是代表質了

    Well, I use "employee members" to distinguish from the "committee members", since we don't know whether it is due to the number of member or what, so it is likely we compare the quality not the quantity.

    2014-09-12 02:40:26 補充:

    As for just "Mr. Smith", because it uses "among the committee members", it gives us an impression it is to compare individual's degree of support. Hence, it leans toward the quantity comparison.

    2014-09-12 02:54:35 補充:

    Oh! Forgot to mention a key point I made; "group". The original sentence use "the most supportive ONE", but after I altered the context, I used "the best supportive group".

    2014-09-12 02:58:00 補充:

    When you use "one", you can compare the quality or the quantity. However, when you use "group", it is likely you don't compare quantity, but the quality. After all, if you compare the quantity, then you can give people a wrong impression by increasing the member number.

    2014-09-12 03:00:20 補充:

    出現比較級最高級the most與 the xxxest時就是代表量 the best就是代表質,假使選項出現這兩種且寫法都是正確的,就依照句子的意思去判斷呢?

    Yes, you got it right! It is not matter of which one to use, but which one is better for the context.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.