One game, super bowl, who would you take? Eli or Peyton Manning?

If this was a couple years ago anybody would have taken Peyton, but as of right now, who would you take? Eli seems to always win the big games, but Peyton is starting to look like the old Peyton, a elite QB.

But if it came down to a win and take all game, who would you choose?
12 answers 12