Is the Confederate Flag Racist?

I just bought a rebel/confederate flag belt buckle and Im kinda nervous to wear it at school. Is it racist?

10 Answers

Relevance
  • Favorite Answer

    Ultimately you have to do a little soul-searching and self-education. Are you up to it? It would be good for you to have some answers at the ready if folks -kids and adults- question why you are wearing the Battle Flag buckle. It's the "teachable moment".

    Here's some things to think about:

    1. I assume that what you have is really called the Confederate Battle Flag (CBF).It is only one of many flags used by the CSA and is not the national flag, although its design was incorporated into the CSA's 2nd and 3rd National Flags.

    2.The Battle Flag is also known as the Southern Cross - since it is derived from the x-shaped cross of St. Andrew, and used on the Saltire flag of Scotland - whence came many of the Southerners. And attests to both an ethnic and religious heritage.

    3. You will readily see that in a battle, with gunsmoke and fog around, it is easy to confuse the USA "Stars & Stripes" and the 1st National CSA flag- "Stars & Bars", especially if there's no wind. So the Southerners needed a distinctive banner particularly for use in battle situations. So, the battle flag should be used to honor the exceptional valor of the soldiers of the South - a fact that is universally acknowledged. It was so well defended that to capture one in battle just about guaranteed a Congressional Medal of Honor.

    4. Also, you should know that all men who served honorably in the armed services of the CSA are, by mandate of the US Congress, the Pentagon, and the Veterans Administration, are to be accounted as US veterans and accorded the same honors as all US Veterans. This includes military gravestones and public monuments for them. Men (and women) who served in other "unpopular" wars, especially Vietnam, appreciate this aspect. The Battle Flag represents patriotism and loyalty to family, home, state and country. Only to the extent that the South was invaded illegally and unconstitutionally, does it represent defiance and resistance. (And that's a whole 'nother topic.)

    5. Teach folks that when the Battle Flag again becomes a familiar feature of the civic landscape, it will cease to be a bogeyman, and will re-assume its role as a recognized symbol of a distinct region and honorable heritage.

    6. You should know that the Confederate states and its citizens were the ones which wanted to uphold the original US Constitution and the Founding Father's vision from the time of the 1st American Revolution. Wearing the CBF represents an appreciation and expression of your Constitutional civil rights- especially freedom of expression. If they don't teach and support this at your school - why not? Are they phony hypocrites, or supportive? Teachers and even principals sometimes need this lesson.

    7. You should look into your own lineage and see if you are descended from a CSA veteran, and have a family link and honorable tradition to uphold; and join the Sons of Confederate Veterans or Children of the Confederacy. ( Or United Daughters of the Confederacy if you are female).

    By wearing the CSA's Battle Flag, you are now joining a righteous crusade. It deserves rehabilitation from those who have exploited it - from the KKK to the NAACP, and this can only be done by brave folks who educate themselves so they can educate others. You might get criticism from ignorant persons , so either educate them or ignore them. Be strong. Stand up for your rights and Southern heritage. And the Confederate flag design just looks great, too.

    David McCalllister, Tampa, FL

    • Login to reply the answers
  • Marie
    Lv 4
    4 years ago

    There are plenty of ignorant people who will respond with ignorance, or emotion, to the question. This is true of any question involving the Confederate battle flag (not the "Stars and Bars", which was a wholly different flag). The truth, though, is that the flag is certainly not "racist". It's easy to put a label like that on anything these days. It's just a term that really has no meaning, but is used to silence those who disagree with you. Read what Charles Dickens, Lord Acton, and others had to say about the war. It wasn't about slavery. It was about the right of self determination--the same thing that the Colonials fought the Revolutionary War over.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • Rance
    Lv 6
    7 years ago

    no more so than any other object - i have a framed, folded nazi flag the my grand father took while liberating a town in sourthern france.

    the confederate flag can be used in a racist manner, like pretty much any other object. it's the use that is the determining factor.

    you should probably check with your school to see if it breaks some type of dress code, but just having one does not equate to racism, you likely will be assumed to be racists, simply because some people are quick to assume without learning why first.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • 7 years ago

    The Confederacy claimed itself to be "the first nation in the history of the world, to be founded upon the principle of African slavery, and white supremacism".

    Aside from the virulent racism it represents. It also represents domestic terrorism, treason, and 360,000 dead US soldiers.

    Read the lyrics to the Confederate ballad I'm a Good Old Rebel", and decide if the sentiments in that song are something you support.

    You're free to wear whatever symbol you like, & other people are free to judge your character accordingly.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 7 years ago

    The Confederate flag is always associated with the American Civil War, which was associated with slavery, which is associated with racism. So yes; generally when people see Confederate flags, they think that the owner might be racist. The Confederate flag can symbolize pride in the south but I'll be honest. When I see it, I typically think of rednecks, racism, and cousin incest.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • 7 years ago

    Only to the uneducated, which is the majority of the liberal left.

    The Confederate symbolizes Southern pride. Since even to this day the south is very much different than the rest of the US and for a brief moment in history they were able to come together and form their own nation before the North declared a war of aggression and forced them back into the union.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    The flag itself is not racist, however it does have that connotation because of its association with slavery, the KKK, and other racists using that as a symbol. You might get a few comments about it.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • 7 years ago

    It's just as racist as people who vote for Obama just because he is black.

    • Login to reply the answers
  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    Trouble makers think it's racist. .

    • Login to reply the answers
  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    Very, it's like having a nazi flag

    • Login to reply the answers
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.