uncle sean asked in 社會與文化語言 · 8 years ago

do something to save 英文區

最近英文區真是暗潮洶湧,抱怨連連,有自問自答情節嚴重者 ,有神秘的午夜灌票部隊,全部指向哈哈大師。不僅讓我回想,當初來這兒替大家解答的初衷還能否維持下去。有一度,這裡因為沒有有能力和熱心的回答者 ,以至於用翻譯軟體魚目混珠的人衝到英文分類高手一名,明明翻譯得只比翻譯軟體略好一 的MM先生成為知識長(此人最近三個月沒有出現),我真的不希望這種惡性循 環出現在英文區,否則有一天這裡也會和語文區一樣,成為只有廣告 ,沒有知識的惡地。

我其實不太喜歡知識家的檢舉功能,過去也只檢舉廣告和什麼迷姦葯之類的,我不知道這是不是唯一可以打擊 哈哈大師的辦法了,諸君有其他良方否?

但是指證明確的檢舉,也許是刪除他不法獲得最佳解答的方式之一,今天我一題一題檢舉了他十個問答:

JIMMY與HA二位一日之內十問答,十題都選HA為最佳解答,這不是作弊,還會是什麼? http://tw.knowledge.yahoo.com/question/question?qi...

Update:

我一點也不在乎 HA大 師成為識長,點數和級別也不能換一碗陽春麵(不過我的確羞與為伍 ),我真的真的在乎 英文區的正確性,請大家提供點建議。

Update 2:

Master HA

What s surprise!

ha ha ha !!!!!!!!!!

Update 3:

十題都在很快時間內選你,不必多說什麼

見過不要臉的,沒見過你這麼 ................可愛的

Update 4:

你用英文回答愈長

曝露的缺點只有愈多

Update 5:

更正

差一個鍵差很多

What s surprise!

What a surprise!

Update 6:

Jimmy很 知羞恥的「也」關檔案不公開,我問 道於何人也??????

Update 7:

but it’s because you are not happy that recently I stole your crown for being the person who had the most numbers of the answers chosen in English section.

to tell the truth.我不爽只是因為你這種半吊子英文可以成為大師而已。如同先前說的,翻譯機也會是英文高手,沒什麼

我堅信:「正確是英文區最低最低的門檻」

而你(sorry), 遠遠達不到

Update 8:

concrete proof????

ha ha ha

一天十問,十題你都答, 你有雷答追到各種不同領域去作答?

人家也很有雷達追著去給佳解答????

我家九個月大大侄兒也只對吃的有反應,不會去追假的NIKE

Update 9:

謝謝你有回應, 有GUTS! 那當大 家在意見欄給你 建犧,你咋都不鳥?????????????

勉強還有一點血淚,把你的假問答撤去 ,這不是我一個人的問題,關心英文區的人明天醒來也在看。

我們 不要假知識,偽投票 ,還有不實的問答。 沒你這樣玩的

17 Answers

Rating
  • 8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    我也忘了自己來知識是多久以前的事了,很多年前了吧?我中間也曾休過好幾次長假,有長達一兩年沒再來......我要說的是,這種事並不是第一次發生,每隔一陣子我就會看到類似的劇碼上演,類似的熱心人士要捍衛知識的正確性,不幸的是,奇摩知識似乎也從沒解決過,隔一陣子走的走散的散,即使是那些亂搞終於成為大師成為知識長的人也不例外(或許是目的達成了,就不再有興趣繼續解答),幾濤浪潮過去,新的一批人再開始陸續加入,時間到了,類似的劇碼再次上演......

    有沒有人真正捍衛了知識我不知道,我只知道這種狀況從來沒有停止過重複,這裡從來不是知識交流更上層樓的聖地,不值得誰拼命想保持它的乾淨,不管是英文區或任何區都一樣。反而我覺得那些因為失望而拂袖而去的能者是更多的,真的很可惜!在我看來,我反而會希望這些真的有實力的人不要在意這些(如同我說的這問題反正從沒被解決過),能盡多少力算多少,不要讓自己失望動氣,畢竟奇摩自身也並沒有要捍衛什麼的意圖,又或許他們也沒那麼多人力編制和專長者去分辨控管,不用期望太大反而把自己逼走......

    (抱歉因為字數太多沒辦法用"發表意見",我只好貼在回答欄位)

  • Anonymous
    6 years ago
  • 8 years ago

    Well..... You still stand on your side over such a childish issue.

    I advise that you stay calm.

    In YK+, Master Ha, I think, just did a commonplace job. When you consider it commonplace, you will find nothing to argue. There is no point in being so angry as well as so childish.

    2012-09-10 02:09:50 補充:

    Let me ask you a question. Do you think you answer others' questions just for the purpose of higher place? or just for "points"? Please think twice.

    2012-09-10 02:10:05 補充:

    I think, I don't know, maybe you'll say that I am also Jack of all trades but master of nothing. Just In view of my record of questions and answers posted in English section, you will catch on why I say so. Believe it or not, I am just going to take GEPT(advanced) this November.

  • 8 years ago

    我們的生活中充滿了壓抑,即使面對種種的不公平、黑白顛倒,只有無奈搖頭; 憤怒不能言。

    Uncle Sean做了件大快人心的事,(掌聲鼓勵)!

    也許有些事實是改變不了,但至少讓大家關注到事實的真相,不再盲目的去相信華麗修飾下的所謂"最佳解答"。

    2012-09-04 20:37:55 補充:

    Dear the_b612,

    您好!您說的正正道出了我跟(部分知道+朋友)的心聲,滿懷希望的來,意興闌珊的淡出。

    但過程中也不乏真正讓我心悅誠服,獲益良多的大師高手如:LionEnglish,Jim Jim, uncle Sean,DaSaGwa,小公主Prisoner26535,羅莉老師,Allen,Citron,荷荷....很多很多.

    不再執著得分多少,得的總比失的多.^_^

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 8 years ago

    其實看了 HA 的回答,也不是全無是處。只不過怎麼看都像是街頭學來的英語,沒真正下過嚴格的基本功。

    有時候他教導發問者的英文,用字非常無禮,根本是痞子用語,自己也茫然不覺。

    對基本文法、詞類、句型都沒有深入了解,所以總是無法做到百分之百精確,老是掛一漏萬。縱然是他聲明中自己高估的數字,也只有「最少也有 90% 正確」。問題是一個句子百分之九十正確,就是錯誤!!! 一句英文少一個 s 都是錯,語言溝通沒有百分之九十正確就算正確這回事。

    但他就是不明白這點!也許他不理解,比他功力差的也都在回答,為什麼就他變成路邊尿桶,眾人撒尿?因為這裡容許功力差,互相切磋,但絕不容許作假!

    2012-09-04 14:38:46 補充:

    沒有品格的人,再高的知識都沒有用!

    灌票可以說是怕輸。自問自答,捨別人更正確的答案不用,選自己不良解答,這會誤導日後爬文學習者。就算不談公平道義,光是為了自己虛榮,貽誤別人學習,就該譴責!

    而一個人竟能做到捏造別人暱稱,來為自己灌票,製造別人支持假象,那已經不是正常人心智了!

    為了無報酬的知識等級虛榮,能變成這樣,實在令人唏噓!

  • 8 years ago

    It takes all sorts to make a world.

    不必做無謂的煩惱:)

  • 8 years ago

    大家好!我是初學者4級的Citron哦,不是那個昨天清晨才誕生的初學者5級的Citron。請大家不要搞錯了。

    因為已經有會回答英文問題的大大來回答了,所以我就把我原來回答欄的資料貼在意見區給大家看。

    2012-09-04 02:21:28 補充:

    Yahoo!奇摩服務中心 > 知識+說明

    問:可以自問自答嗎?

    答:不可以!相同的帳號無法在同一個問題發問又回答。同時也嚴格禁止多重帳號互拱點數!若經查證屬實,Yahoo!奇摩將立即刪除問答並扣除點數,情節嚴重者將給予停權處分。

    http://help.cc.tw.yahoo.com/help_cp.html?id=899

    2012-09-04 02:21:41 補充:

    我是如何蒐尋到以上資料的?

    1. Yahoo奇摩知識+網頁

    2. 右上角三個小按鈕中的第二個:「服務說明」

    3. 在「問題搜尋」 的欄位輸入「自問自答」

    4. 在欄位右邊的下拉式選單(服務項目)選「知識+」

    5. 按「搜尋」

    您就會看到第一筆資料是:

    1.可以自問自答嗎?

    點進去您就會看到以上內容。

    2012-09-04 02:21:59 補充:

    哦,uncle sean,我想應該是有些初學者不知道Yahoo奇摩知識+的規定,所以才會犯錯。所以我就把以上內容PO在這裡給大家看。我以前真的看過有人因為自問自答而被停權的哦。所以我覺得大家最好不要犯這樣的錯啦。

    以一個發問者的立場來說,自問自答真的會浪費大家的網路和人力資源。譬如說,我Citron明明有一題很急的、真正需要大師們幫忙的英文問題在發問,但若大師們都把時間用在回答自問自答的問題上了,那我的問題就會比較晚才受到關注囉。所以我覺得,自問自答不但違反Yahoo奇摩知識+的規定,同時也是不道德的。所以大家最好不要自問自答啦。大家都真實地發問,真實地回答,這樣比較好。

  • 8 years ago

    I am sure people are smart enough to distinguish the correct answer from the wrong one. Sometimes, it's just that obvious. Besides, take those bad answers as a comic relief.

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    Uncle sean… I usually don’t reply to this kind of topic which you are asking now, because you simply relate me to Jimmy without having concrete proof that we are the same guy. Why don’t you ask Jimmy instead why he chose all my answers to be the answers? Falsely accusing someone of something without any proof just makes you sound immature. Not only wouldn’t I use other accounts to ask and answer them all by myself, but I wouldn’t also use other accounts to vote the answers I liked. You seem to act as if you are right about all your assumptions, but it’s because you are not happy that recently I stole your crown for being the person who had the most numbers of the answers chosen in English section. Simply put, that is not my goal. My goal here is to help those who really want to learn English. I wish to convey my knowledge to them that one day the things they learnt from my will be very helpful for them in lives. Let just put what you concern aside, we are here to help people to learn English as well as sharing our wisdoms, right? AM I RIGHT? You always point out that my answers that have been nominated have full of errors, you know what! That is your personal bias. Having said this, I wish you understand that I am here to help and make friends, not to mislead people.

    2012-09-04 00:55:24 補充:

    uncle sean, it is useless to argue with you since

    you only want to say what you like and what makes you feel you

    are right.

    Shame on you!!!I am not gonna waste my time on some troll like you.

    Hear me huh, troll!!!

    2012-09-04 01:07:59 補充:

    Say anything you want...

    Yeah, my English sux, and I am sure you would only get "F" as your grade for

    your English reports. At least I know how to make sense of the answer I am giving.

    Keep saying what you want, u r not gonna change my mind.

    I am who I am, and you will always be who you are.

    2012-09-04 01:21:11 補充:

    To people new here, ignore this guy and some of his allies.

    They are biased and try to make fun of the people whose answers they don't like.

    ...nuff said.

    Source(s): ME
  • Hsiang
    Lv 5
    8 years ago

    我是新加入的.....還看不出來哪些人跟哪些人有啥關連 原來知識家是波濤洶湧的阿...

    2012-09-04 01:02:51 補充:

    OHOH~~~~The timmin the aruging too lot to consider t_t

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.