But in things like The Losers…I think he did a great job and was funny and clever with great comedic timing (also in Scott Pilgrim vs. the World --- both not so good movies overall).
I just get the feeling that he’s better than what he’s done/been doing.
I felt the same way about Hugh Jackman until I saw The Prestige, and then I was thankful that he was in something really great.
People like Alan Rickman and Gary Oldman don't count, IMO, though....they aren't underrated (they maybe should have been nominated/won won some more awards than they have....but that doesn't mean that people don't acknowlege their acting ability). Same with Cillian Murphy -- just b/c he hasn't been in many major films doens't mean that everyone and their mother doesn't know he's an amazing actor.
Thanks for the list though, guys! Keep 'em coming.