eli is hardly top 6 or top 8.. Eli just plays on a good team with good defense and that is well rounded. He is helping the team but he does not carry the team nor does he or is he responsible for most of there wins as he is not a QB that saves the day he is not even that great of a QB in terms of stats.
Peyton Career QB RAT: 94.9, 54828 yards, 399 TD
Peyton last season QB RAT:
Eli Career QB RAT: 82.1
Eli Season Rat: 92.1, 29579 yards, 185 TD
Eli is not that accurate or great as peyton is. Peyton is top 3 QB in the league when he is playing or top 4...
There are many many more stats Peyton is a much better QB..
A team winning the super bowl is not because of a QB Its the whole team. You have a great QB like stafford on a team like the lions that sucks in a lot of places thus losses games. You have a great QB like #4 ranked romo in the league, playing on a team with good offense but horrible defense and bad coaching thus they lose games... Does not mean stafford is a bad QB or Romo is, they just are unlucky to be playing for teams that are not so great.
Than you got a QB like Roethlisberger he is good but on a great team that is well rounded with a damn good defense. Rothlisberger may seem better than some other QB but he is not though id say he is top 10 as is eli.. Anyhow rothelisberger is far from carrying the team.
Than you got QB like rodgers, and manning and brady without them the team offense falls apart and they are not good elsewhere they they struggle.