Anonymous asked in Computers & InternetInternetOther - Internet · 8 years ago

So, I'm running sale ads on Craigslist, response has been having my ad emailed back to me?

Many of these emails have come back from people who have the same (unusual) last name, but different first names. Some responses have simply been asking if I still have the item for sale.

What is the scam?

What are they attempting to do, and how do I avoid their traps?


Aaargh! They are both excellent answers! Thank you both!

Now I have to choose the best?!?

I guess the right thing to do is pick the one that came in first...

2 Answers

  • 8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    These are all scams to steal your item. They will either send you a fake paypal notification as explained in this article or they will pay you with a counterfeit check/money order which will initially clear, then bounce 3 weeks later, after you've sent off the item

    A scammer will never mention the specific item you are selling. They say "Is the item still available" or "I am satisfied with the condition and want to buy" -- because they send that exact email to every single seller no matter what they are selling

    A real buyer will always mention the specific item, will almost always try to negotiate the price down (a scammer will offer MORE money or offer to pay for shipping), and will give you their phone number and try to arrange a time to meet you

    Remember, Craigslist is ONLY for face to face cash transactions. Period. If you can't meet in a public well lit location and accept cash you will get screwed every time. Anyone who can't meet you is a scam. Anyone who wants the item shipped or to have their 'shipper' or 'agent' pick it up is a scam. Anyone offering you more money is a scam. Anyone claiming to be out of town/out of the country is a scam. Anyone wanting to pay with paypal, money order or cashiers check is a scam

    Any time I list anything 90% of the people responding are scammers

    I always meet the buyer in person at my local Starbucks but any public location is fine - hotel lobby, bank lobby, Walmart, fast food, etc. But if they cannot meet you and pay cash then do not respond

    And NEVER give your home address to any buyer for any reason. Do you know how many people have already been targeted for home invasion robberies by fake Craigslist buyers, including one man who was murdered when "buyers" came to his home to pick up the item he had for sale

    Read Craigslist's very clear warnings

    • Login to reply the answers
  • 8 years ago

    100% scam.

    There is no buyer.

    Notice how the scammer doesn't call what you are selling by name? He uses the generic word "item", that is because he sends the same stock copy/paste email to anyone selling everything that he can find and he has no idea what you are selling and doesn't care.

    There is only a scammer trying to steal your hard-earned money.

    He is not interested in what you are selling, your identity or bank account, only your cash.

    The next email will be from another of the scammer's fake names and free email addresses pretending to be the "secretary/assistant/accountant" and will demand you cash a large fake check sent on a stolen UPS/FedEx billing account number and send the money via Western Union or moneygram back to the scammer posing as the "shipping company". When your bank realizes the check is fake and it bounces, you get the real life job of paying back the bank for the bounced check fees and all the bank's money you sent to an overseas criminal.

    Western Union and moneygram do not verify anything on the form the sender fills out, not the name, not the street address, not the country, not even the gender of the receiver, it all means absolutely nothing. The clerk will not bother to check ID and will simply hand off your cash to whomever walks in the door with the MTCN# and question/answer. Neither company will tell the sender who picked up the cash, at what store location or even in what country your money walked out the door. Neither company has any kind of refund policy, money sent is money gone forever.

    When you refuse to send him your cash he will send increasingly nasty and rude emails trying to convince you to go through with his scam. The scammer could also create another fake name and email address like "FBI@", "police_person" or "investigator" and send emails telling you the job is legit and you must cash the fake check and send your money to the scammer or you will face legal action. Just ignore, delete and block those email addresses. Although, reading a scammer's attempt at impersonating a law enforcement officer can be extremely funny.

    Now that you have responded to a scammer, you are on his 'potential sucker' list, he will try again to separate you from your cash. He will send you more emails from his other free email addresses using another of his fake names with all kinds of stories of being the perfect buyer, great jobs, lottery winnings, millions in the bank and desperate, lonely, sexy singles. He will sell your email address to all his scamming buddies who will also send you dozens of fake emails all with the exact same goal, you sending them your cash via Western Union or moneygram.

    You could post up the email address and the emails themselves that the scammer is using, it will help make your post more googlable for other suspicious potential victims to find when looking for information.

    Do you know how to check the header of a received email? If not, you could google for information. Being able to read the header to determine the geographic location an email originated from will help you weed out the most obvious scams and scammers. Then delete and block that scammer. Don't bother to tell him that you know he is a scammer, it isn't worth your effort. He has one job in life, convincing victims to send him their hard-earned cash.

    Whenever suspicious or just plain curious, google everything, website addresses, names used, companies mentioned, phone numbers given, all email addresses, even sentences from the emails as you might be unpleasantly surprised at what you find already posted online. You can also post/ask here and every scam-warner-anti-fraud-busting site you can find before taking a chance and losing money to a scammer.

    If you google "fake check buyer scam", "fake Western Union buyer fraud" or something similar and you will find hundreds of posts of victims and near victims of this type of scam.

    • Login to reply the answers
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.