Fantasy Football RB start week 1?

If you had to choose between Marshawn Lynch or Mike Tolbert to start week 1, who would you feel most comfortable starting and having a prosperous Sunday? The rest of my starting roster is this.. QB: P. Rivers SDG WR: D. Jackson PHI WR: W. Welker NE WR: A. Boldin BAL RB: A. Peterson MIN RB: M. Jones-Drew... show more If you had to choose between Marshawn Lynch or Mike Tolbert to start week 1, who would you feel most comfortable starting and having a prosperous Sunday?

The rest of my starting roster is this..

QB: P. Rivers SDG
WR: D. Jackson PHI
WR: W. Welker NE
WR: A. Boldin BAL
RB: A. Peterson MIN
RB: M. Jones-Drew JAC
TE: A. Gates SDG
WR/RB: ????????????????? (Thinking Lynch or Tolbert)
K: M. Bryant ATL
D/ST: NY Jets

Other options on my bench are limited.. K. Kolb ARZ QB, B. Jacobs NYG RB, R. Jennings JAC RB, H. Ward PIT WR, J. Nelson GB WR.

So Lynch or Tolbert is the question..
Update: This was an AUCTION league draft, in case you're curious about how my roster looks like this.. with a complete drop off in talent when it comes to my bench.
Update 2: Rivers $35, MJD $30, Gates $17, Welker $15, Boldin $12, DJax $24, AP $52, Jets $3, Kolb $3, Tolbert $3.. rest were $1 bids or free agents after the draft.
2 answers 2