Big Fantasy Baseball Trade, should I do it?

Question

12 Team, Head to Head, PPR League. I'm in 2nd place, 13 GB, the other guy is in 5th place, 25 GB.

I Recieve:

Roy Halladay (SP)

Francisco Rodriguez (RP)

Prince Fielder (1B)

Jemile Weeks (2B)

Jhonny Peralta (3B, SS)

I Give:

Jhoulys Chacin (SP)

Sergio Santos (RP)

Adrain Gonzalez (1B)

Ian Kinsler (2B)

Chris Young (OF)

His Hitters:

Yadier Molina (C)

Prince Fielder (1B)

Jemile Weeks (2B)

Jhonny Peralta (3B, SS)

Elvis Andrus (SS)

Brennan Boesch (OF)

Melky Cabrera (OF)

Ryan Ludwick (OF)

Michael Morse (1B, OF)

Matt Joyce (OF)

Stephen Drew (SS) (Out for Year)

My Hitting:

Russell Martin (C)

Adrian Gonzalez (1B)

Ian Kinsler (2B)

Adrian Beltre (3B)

Jimmy Rollins (SS)

Chris Young (OF)

Jeff Francoeur (OF)

Hunter Pence (OF)

Emilio Bonifacio (3B, SS, OF)

Travis Hafner (Util)

Billy Butler (1B)

Darwin Barney (2B, SS)

Josh Reddick (OF)

His Pitching:

Roy Halladay (SP)

Cliff Lee (SP)

Justin Verlander (SP)

David Price (SP)

Roy Oswalt (SP) On the DL

Francisco Rodriguez (RP)

Chris Carpenter (SP)

Madison Bumgarner (SP)

Kevin Gregg (RP)

Ryan Vogelsong (SP, RP)

Freddy Garcia (SP)

Matt Lindstrom (RP)

Tim Wakefield (SP, RP)

My Pitching:

Ian Kennedy (SP)

Jeff Karstens (SP, RP)

Jhoulys Chacin (SP, RP)

Antonio Bastardo (RP)

Sergio Santos (RP)

Daniel Bard (RP)

Chris Perez (RP)

Mike Adams (RP)

Bartolo Colon (SP)

Cory Luebke (SP, RP)

Scott Baker (SP) On the DL

Should I do the trade? If not, should I make a different trade? Thanks.

Answer 1

Favorite Answer

I like the the trade, but I would make one difference: see if you can get Morse instead of Peralta.

Answer 2

this is a tough one

u get better pitching out of Halladay than from Chacin

u are going to lose saves cause Felix is not the closer for the Brewers, but Santos hasnt had a save since July 1st

Gonzalez and Fielder is a good for either team

Kinsler is the better than Jemile Weeks

Peralta is a big bat and will replace Young well

maybe put Darwin Barney instead of Kinlser, if u can switch those two it would be a good trade

Answer 3

I agree with the previous answers but maybe see if you can get k-rod and Santos taken out of the deal.

Actually, on second thought, the rosters indicate to me that this may be a holds league. In that case, Santos and K-Rod are pretty much equal.