PITT asked in Business & FinanceInvesting · 9 years ago

Is the stock market a better choice?

I'm only 18 but I'm starting to save money for the future. I have some money in savings, but I'm putting a lot into stocks and am starting to look at mutual funds. I wasn't sure if that pays the best down the road or if I should put it all in savings, or a CD, or savings bonds. Which would be best?

7 Answers

  • John W
    Lv 7
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    If you define the best as long term growth of your portfolio then the answer is according to the probabilities and the return keeping in mind that there are limits to reasonable risk. For example, using a pure 50/50 coin toss as the epitome of risk, if you had a chance to wager on as many coin tosses as you'd like one at a time at 2 to 1 payout where if you win you won twice your wager and your wager would be returned to you while if you lost you would lose your wager, how much would you wager with each coin toss. The payout is favourable, in the long run for every $1 lost you should be making $1.50 so the more you wager, the more you stand to win. If you wager nothing then you win nothing and you lose nothing but if you wager everything you have with each coin toss, you are only guaranteeing that you will lose everything eventually so what is the optimal wager to maximize the growth of your portfolio? John L. Kelly when applying Claude Shannon's (the father of the information age) information theory realized that the optimum in a binary situation could be calculated by the equation:

    f = (bp - q ) / b

    where f is the fraction of your portfolio to wager, b is the payout, p is the probability of a win and q is the probability of a loss which in this example gives you:

    f = ( 2 * 0.5 - 0.5 ) / 2 = 0.25

    This is known as the Kelly Criterion. Unbeknowst to Kelly, Daniel Bernoulli had proposed the geometric mean of outcome as the appropriate measure for investment in 1738, hence the appropriate wager f for the aforementioned coin toss would be such that the following would be at a maximum:

    e^( q * ln( 1 - f ) + p * ln( 1 + b * f ) )

    which is at a maximum at f = 0.25

    The Bernoulli approach requires iterative methods to solve (trial and error) but allows for multiple outcomes, outcomes that do not include a total lose and concurrent events (concurrent events are just more outcomes).

    The equations actually show that if you wager more than 50% of your portfolio, you will actually be losing money even though it's a money making opportunity.

    If you could wager on two such coin tosses at a time, again as often as you'd like, the optimal wager becomes 23% on each coin toss thereby risking 46% of your capital instead of the mere 25% and you start losing money when you wager more than 40% on each coin toss instead of the 50%, so you can risk up to 80% of your portfolio before losing money instead of the 50% with the single coin toss at a time scenario. So with more investment opportunities, you can invest a greater portion of your portfolio.

    What this exemplifies is that there are limits to risk and you should never be fully invested so long as there is a risk of total loss. It also shows that diversification allows you to have more of your portfolio invested while still achieving the optimum for growth.

    Our natural inclination is towards excessive risk, this is because we've evolved to be risk takers. To evolution, it doesn't matter if most of us fail so long as a few are obscenely successful. Hence your natural tendency will be to over bet and though that increases the chance of someone becoming very wealthy, it virtually guarantees that you will not. If you want to be personally rich, you will have to fight your own innate judgement of risk. You will often hear the advice to be aggressive when young but the opportunity value of what you risk when you're young is much greater then that of the same dollar amount when you are older, you should start off conservative because you have less and you will be holding your investments longer which means they will surely have to face a market downturn. You will hear the advice to invest in an aggressive 100% stock fund, mathematically such a portfolio guarantees a dibilitating loss as an eventuality, the optimum for growth can and has been proven by Claude Shannon at MIT to be 50/50. Ben Graham has written that the optimum is likely to be 45% invested in stocks and 55% in bonds. There is significant opportunity value in what you don't invest, it's what allows you to take advantage of a market downturn by simply rebalancing. The cash in your portfolio acts as a ratchet or one way valve so that you can benefit from both price increases and price drops. A 100% portfolio can do nothing in a downturn except lose money, to a 50/50 portfolio, a market downturn is a wonderful buying opportunity.

    The best will not be all in stocks or all in savings or bonds, the best will be a portfolio of several investments according to the risk and the returns.

    Read a few books, learn about risk, read "Fortune's Formula" by William Poundstone.

  • 4 years ago

    Both are good. Choice is yours. The difference is you have to borrow money to get into real estate which places a heavy liability on your financial station in life. Although most are not concerned with this, it is still an obligation that must be fulfilled by you once you sign on the line. With the stock market, you can also leverage i.e. Forex, but your margin is due at the end of the day. The stock market is a good place to take any amount of money and invest. As with any industry, the success of your investment will depend on how good you do your homework. Individual stocks need two things, value and a catalyst for success. Mutual funds can be great, too. Both real estate and the stock market are subject to substantial instability. While the stock market could crash heavily in one day, you can sell shares most anytime the market is open. With real estate, getting out of an investment property can take months or sometimes years. You can also invest in the real estate market through the stock market with what are called REIT's or Real-Estate-Investment-Trusts. It is kind of like a mutual fund for real estate. I recommend reading some good books before getting started. If you rely to heavily on outside sources to tell you what to buy and when, you are setting yourself up for confusion. Invest in what you know. If you are familiar with online advertising for example, you might consider looking into these stocks. This will give you an edge when you start trading. Be unemotional. The most important thing to know in the stock market is when to sell. Buy low, sell high. Easy, right? Well a lot of folks get too wrapped up in news headlines that results in them selling stocks prematurely instead of remembering that they are investing for the long haul. Be blessed,

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    Binary options let users trade in currency pairs and stocks for various predetermined time-periods, minimal of which is 30 seconds. Executing trades is straightforward. The system uses user-friendly interfaces, which even an 8 years old kid, can operate without having to read any instructions. But winning trades is Not easy.

    Binary trading is advertised as the only genuine system that lets users earn preposterous amounts of money in ridiculously short period of time. Advertisers try to implicate as if you can make $350 every 60 seconds; if it was true then binary trading would truly be an astonishing business.

    However, does it make any sense? Can every trader make tons of money in binary trading? Who is actually paying all the money or the profit to traders?

    The first challenge is finding a trustworthy binary broker; secondly, you need to find a binary trading strategy, which you can use to make profits consistently. Without an effective trading strategy, there is no way you can make money in this business.

    Learning a profitable trading strategy is possible, You should watch this presentation video https://tr.im/16635

    It's probably the best way to learn how to win with binary option

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    If you want to earn money with binary trading and you aren't a big expert you definitely need some kind of support. I use a software called "autobinary signals" and I earning good money with it. Here you can find all the details and also some video proofs: http://tradingsignal.toptips.org

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 5 years ago

    the best trading software http://tradingsolution.info

    i have attended a lot of seminars, read counless books on forex trading and it all cost me thousands of dollars. the worst thing was i blew up my first account. after that i opened another account and the same thing happened again. i started to wonder why i couldn,t make any money in forex trading. at first i thought i knew everything about trading. finally i found that the main problem i have was i did not have the right mental in trading. as we know that psychology has great impact on our trading result. apart from psychology issue, there is another problem that we have to address. they are money management, market analysis, and entry/exit rules. to me money management is important in trading. i opened another account and start to trade profitably after i learnt from my past mistake. i don't trade emotionally anymore.

    if you are serious about trading you need to address your weakness and try to fix it. no forex guru can make you Professional trader unless you want to learn from your mistake.

  • 9 years ago

    Stock Market...without a doubt....but its not easy...Learn how to trade, learn technical analisys...use stop loss, risk-management...most people dont believe they could win in the stock market because they dont know anything....

  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    "Best" is diversification of your savings and investments - and "best" also depends on your nearer-term needs. Read "Investing For Dummies" - it's well worth the $15 or so.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.