Where is the law that requires a Doctor to pay for an income tax?
“A tax laid upon the happening of an event, as distinguished from its tangible fruit
Tyler v. United States, 281 U.S. 497, at 502 (1930)”
Another words a tax laid on an activity (event) as distinguished from its tangible fruit (property or income) is an indirect tax. Therefore the subject of the income tax is the activity that produces the income, and not the income itself. It would be an illogical conundrum to believe that the subject of an excise tax is the income. Here is another example of an indirect tax: When we pay a toll (tax) to cross a bridge, the thing being taxed is not the bridge, clearly, but the event (activity) of crossing the bridge. We are being taxed (fee) for the use of the bridge. In the payment of the toll (tax) it would not be logical to state that taxing the toll (tax) is the subject of the tax. That would mean that we are being tax for the collection of a tax!
1)the subject of an excise tax (indirect tax) is the activity,
2)that the 16th Amendment did not create the income tax (the constitutional authority is in Article 1, Section 8, Clause 1 of the Constitution)
3)That the 16th Amendment is not Title 26 (Internal Revenue Code).
4)That mumbling amongst yourself that there is a law, does not constitute law.
5)That making references to income is not addressing the subject of the income tax as in "There is hereby imposed on the taxable income of— "
6)That the statement “whatever source derived” means (according to the supreme court) all income taxes are indirect taxes from whatever source derived.
7)That any law that provides rules for collecting taxes must contend with the 6th Amendment's nature and cause, and explain, at least generally address the particular activity that is being taxed.
You are a taxpayer
You have taxable income
how do you become a taxpayer?
Because you have taxable income.
What makes your income taxable?
Because you are a taxpayer!
So the question is: I am a Doctor where in Title 26 does it say that any profession, trade, employment, or vocation is a taxable event.
There are only three possible subjects of taxation in the entire world. There are no others. A government can tax property, they can tax people (as in capitation taxes when there was slavery), and they can tax activities (or variants thereof). There is simply no other logical taxable subjects anywhere. In the United States , the founding fathers addressed these as either direct or indirect taxes. We know for certain that a direct tax is a tax on property and
"Excises are taxes laid upon the manufacture, sale or consumption of commodities within the country, upon licenses to pursue certain (licensed) occupations and upon corporate privileges; the requirement to pay such taxes involves the exercise of privilege."
Flint vs Stone Tracy Co. 220 U.S. 107 (1911)
"Direct taxes bear immediately upon persons, upon possessions and enjoyment of rights. Indirect taxes are levied upon the happening of an event or an exchange."
Knowlton v. Moore 178 U.S. 41 (1900)
So once more: The Income Tax is an indirect tax:
“The Sixteenth Amendment simply prohibited the power of income taxation from being taken out of the category of indirect taxation”
Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co., 240 U.S. 103, at 112 (1916)
1) So it is clear that the income tax is an excise tax (indirect
3) We also understand that the law for the collection of the Income tax resides within Title 26.
The question remains:
I am a Doctor where in Title 26 does it say that any profession, trade, employment, or vocation is a taxable event.
Dont repeat what has already been stated.