Why do Americans believe that Mexican legal and illegal immigrants don't contribute to the United States?

Ok, many of you think that Mexican immigration in all forms doesn't contribute to the United States and they refuse to learn English. What do you say about the following list of notable Mexican-Americans that came here as immigrants. General Richard E. Cavazos Medal of Honor recipient, Roy Benevidez Guy... show more Ok, many of you think that Mexican immigration in all forms doesn't contribute to the United States and they refuse to learn English. What do you say about the following list of notable Mexican-Americans that came here as immigrants.
General Richard E. Cavazos
Medal of Honor recipient, Roy Benevidez
Guy Gabaldon

* Bertrand Blanchard Acosta - Aviator, Fighter Pilot
* Lucian Adams - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Everett Alvarez Jr. - Navy LCdr/Pilot who endured 8.5 years in Vietnamese captivity and one of the longest periods as a U.S. prisoner of war (POW)
* David B. Barkley - Medal of Honor (World War I)
* Roy Benavidez - Medal of Honor (Vietnam War)
* Robert Cardenas - U.S. Air Force Brigadier General
* Richard E. Cavazos - first U.S. Army Hispanic 4-star general, Distinguished Service Cross (Korea and Vietnam)
* Kathlene Contres - U.S. Navy
* Ralph Ellis Dias - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Daniel Fernandez - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* José María Flores - General and Governor of Alta California (Mexican American War)
* Guy Gabaldon - Navy Cross recipient, credited with capturing (or persuading to surrender) about 1,500 Japanese soldiers and civilians during the Battle of Saipan (World War II)
* Marcario Garcia - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Emilio A. De La Garza - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Edward Gomez- Medal of Honor (Korean War)
* David M. Gonzales(1923–1945) - Medal of Honor (World War II) First in Los Angeles
* Alfredo Cantu Gonzalez - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Freddy Gonzalez - Medal of Honor, KIA in Huế (Vietnam)
* Harold Gonsalves - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Ricardo Sanchez - United States Army General & Author
* Ambrosio Guillen- Medal of Honor (Korean War)
* Rodolfo P. Hernandez - Medal of Honor (Korean War)
* Silvestre S. Herrera - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Edward Hidalgo - former Secretary of the Navy
* Jose F. Jimenez - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Miguel Keith - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Felix Z. Longoria, Jr. - first Mexican American buried in Arlington National Cemetery (World War II)
* Jose M. Lopez- Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Nicolas Lucero - French Croix de guerre (World War I)
* Louis Gonzaga Mendez Jr. - West Point Graduate, Distinguished Service Medal (World War II)
* Benito Martinez - Medal of Honor (Korean War)
* Joe P. Martinez - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Louis Gonzaga Mendez, Jr. - highly decorated Colonel, commander of the 3rd Battalion, 508th Parachute Infantry Regiment (World War II)
* Francisco Mercado, Jr. - Distinguished Service Cross
* Eugene A. Obregon- Medal of Honor (Korean War)
* Rafael Peralta - Navy Cross (Operation Iraqi Freedom)
* Oscar F. Perdomo - United States Air Force Flying ace (World War II)
* Manuel Perez Jr. - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Lori Piestewa(1973–2003) - the first woman in the U.S. armed forces killed in the 2003 Iraq war[122]
* Alfred V. Rascon - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Louis R. Rocco - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Cleto Rodriguez - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Joseph C. Rodriguez - Medal of Honor (Korean War)
* Alejandro R. Ruiz - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Ricardo Sanchez- Retired Lieutenant General (Operation Iraqi Freedom)
* Marcelino Serna - Distinguished Service Cross (World War I)
* France Silva - Medal of Honor (Boxer Rebellion)

[123]

* Eugene Suarez - U.S. Marine, war photographer, World War II and Korea
* Jose F. Valdez - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Eugene A. Valencia, Jr. - Flying Ace (World War II), Navy Cross
* Alfred Valenzuela -Major General, United States Army
* Jay R. Vargas - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Ysmael R. Villegas - Medal of Honor (World War II)
* Maximo Yabes - Medal of Honor (Vietnam)
* Albert Baez - physicist and professor, developed the X-ray microscope
* Elsa Salazar Cade - science educator and entomologist
* Victor Celorio - Inventor of Instabook or Book On Demand [130]
* France A. Córdova - former NASA Chief Scientist
* Henry Eyring - theoretical chemist, writer, and recipient of the National Medal of Science award
* Sidney M. Gutierrez - former astronaut[131]
* Jose Hernández (astronaut) - astronaut[132]
* Robert Navarro - NASA project manager for the ER-2 high-altitude, long-range flying laboratories at Dryden.[133]
* Ellen Ochoa - astronaut, director for flight crew operations for NASA[134]
* John D. Olivas - NASA astronaut[135]
* Eloy Rodriguez - biochemist, professor at Cornell University
* Ted Taylor - physicist and nuclear weapons designer
* Alfredo Quinones-Hinojosa, M.D. - Associate Professor of Neurosurgery and Oncology. Director of the Brain Tumor Stem Cell Laboratory at Johns Hopkins University and brain surgeon at John
Update: Journalists * Miguel Almaguer - TV Reporter [91] * Ron Arias - Highly Regarded Chicano Writer & Correspondent * Gustavo Arellano - an editor at the Los Angeles Times and writer/creator of ¡Ask a Mexican! * Jim Avila - TV Journalist & Correspondent * María Antonieta Collins - TV Host,... show more Journalists

* Miguel Almaguer - TV Reporter [91]
* Ron Arias - Highly Regarded Chicano Writer & Correspondent
* Gustavo Arellano - an editor at the Los Angeles Times and writer/creator of ¡Ask a Mexican!
* Jim Avila - TV Journalist & Correspondent
* María Antonieta Collins - TV Host, Journalist, & Author
* Laura Diaz - Southern California Newscaster & Co-Anchor of CBS 2 News
* Giselle Fernández - TV Journalist & Reporter
* Luis De La Garza - TV & Radio Host
* Christy Haubegger - Movie Producer & Founder of Latina Magazine
* Maria Hinojosa - Broadcast Journalist & Correspondent
* Raul Peimbert - Spanish-language TV Journalist & Newscaster
* John Quiñones - News correspondent, and an Award winning Journalist
* Jorge Ramos - Spanish-language TV News Anchor & Journalist
* Naibe Reynoso - TV Journalist & Reporter
* Rubén Salazar - TV Journalist & Reporter
* María Elena Salinas - Spanish-Language TV News Anchor & Journalist
Update 2: Political Figures Romualdo Pacheco Governor of California Bill Richardson Ken Salazar Romana Acosta Bañuelos * Toney Anaya - US Democratic Politician & Former Governor of New Mexico[99] * Ernesto Ruffo Appel - Politician & Former Governor of Baja California * Romana Acosta Bañuelos - former Treasurer... show more Political Figures
Romualdo Pacheco Governor of California
Bill Richardson
Ken Salazar
Romana Acosta Bañuelos

* Toney Anaya - US Democratic Politician & Former Governor of New Mexico[99]
* Ernesto Ruffo Appel - Politician & Former Governor of Baja California
* Romana Acosta Bañuelos - former Treasurer of the United States
* Mike Aguirre - former city attorney of San Diego, California
* Xavier Becerra - U.S. Representative (CA-31)[100]
* Cruz Bustamante - former California lieutenant governor[101]
* Raul Hector Castro - governor of Arizona
* Anna Escobedo Cabral - 42nd Treasurer of the United States
* Rosemary Barkett - federal judge
* Lauro Cavazos - secretary of education[102]
* Gabe Cazares - former mayor of Clearwater, Florida
* Dennis Chavez - U.S. Senator from New Mexico[103]
* Henry Cisneros - former Secretary of Housing and Urban Development and mayor of San Antonio, Texas[104]
* Mario Gallegos, Jr. - Texas state senator
Update 3: Political Figures Romualdo Pacheco Governor of California Bill Richardson Ken Salazar Romana Acosta Bañuelos * Toney Anaya - US Democratic Politician & Former Governor of New Mexico[99] * Ernesto Ruffo Appel - Politician & Former Governor of Baja California * Romana Acosta Bañuelos - former Treasurer... show more Political Figures
Romualdo Pacheco Governor of California
Bill Richardson
Ken Salazar
Romana Acosta Bañuelos

* Toney Anaya - US Democratic Politician & Former Governor of New Mexico[99]
* Ernesto Ruffo Appel - Politician & Former Governor of Baja California
* Romana Acosta Bañuelos - former Treasurer of the United States
* Mike Aguirre - former city attorney of San Diego, California
* Xavier Becerra - U.S. Representative (CA-31)[100]
* Cruz Bustamante - former California lieutenant governor[101]
* Raul Hector Castro - governor of Arizona
* Anna Escobedo Cabral - 42nd Treasurer of the United States
* Rosemary Barkett - federal judge
* Lauro Cavazos - secretary of education[102]
* Gabe Cazares - former mayor of Clearwater, Florida
* Dennis Chavez - U.S. Senator from New Mexico[103]
* Henry Cisneros - former Secretary of Housing and Urban Development and mayor of San Antonio, Texas[104]
* Mario Gallegos, Jr. - Texas state senator
Update 4: Show me a peer-review journal that shows that illegal immigrants kills 10,000 Americans a year and I will believe you.......its funny that you wont be able to get none because its all lies
Update 5: @Candie show me a peer-review academic journal that shows studies backing up your argument, I bet you wont find any because your argument is bogus only based on anti-immigrant propaganda. If you can prove it with a non-partisan independent study peer-review academic journal I will believe all your words and believe... show more @Candie show me a peer-review academic journal that shows studies backing up your argument, I bet you wont find any because your argument is bogus only based on anti-immigrant propaganda. If you can prove it with a non-partisan independent study peer-review academic journal I will believe all your words and believe as you do.
4 answers 4