Best Answer: ORIGINAL all the way!!....my reasons are this...
1) CM Punk is overrated and is more of a tyrant / oppressor than a leader.
2) The original Nexus had more members and made a bigger impact in their first few weeks on Raw
3)The "New" Nexus didn't make the impact that the original members made.
4) The original Nexus had better promos and it was a fresh angle for the WWE
5) The original Nexus had a PURPOSE as a group of NXT rookies that strive to get revenge on the WWE pros / management for the abuse and ridicule they had to go through. The New Nexus defeated that purpose by just being a cult that follows CM Punk like he's their god.
Whatever way you put it , nothing beats the original. The rebellious NXT rookies formed what was known as the NEXUS (A bond or connection) to make a name for themselves in the WWE.
Source(s): " You're either Nexus or you're against us " - Wade Barrett
I feel the new Nexus is almost a cult. Plus I can never take CM Punk serious he ask to much like a little boy. I also would enjoy seeing Mason Ryan under the lead of Wade Barrett with in the Original Nexus. It would have been interesting and dangerous.
I like the original more. But each week the New Nexus is getting better and better. With all these new superstars. I hated seeing Wade Barrett forming another group after eaving Nexus. I would love to see him compete completely alone soon. Same with Justin Gabriel.