Ben Roethlisberger Is Better Than Tom Brady and Peyton Manning?

Now he is going to be a CERTIFIED HOF. He might not put up numbers like you "crave" but he finds a way to win games. Especially when his defense screw it up like 2 years ago vs. Arizona. Unlike Peyton or Tom he FINDS a way to win. Last week versus Jets he single handedly took over and picked apart the 1#... show more Now he is going to be a CERTIFIED HOF. He might not put up numbers like you "crave" but he finds a way to win games. Especially when his defense screw it up like 2 years ago vs. Arizona.
Unlike Peyton or Tom he FINDS a way to win. Last week versus Jets he single handedly took over and picked apart the 1# defense in the league.

Meanwhile Tom and Peyton are at home because they CHOKED in the playoffs like MOST of the time. I swear you fantasy nuthuggers are mad because he does not get 70 TD's every season or something. He gets the job done. There have been times when the whole team collapsed and played like crap but he got the job done in the end. He did it in both Super Bowls and will do it again.

He is already better than both and is now a top 10 all time.

1. Joe Montana
2. Brett Favre
3. Terry Bradshaw
4. John Elway
5. Steve Young
6. Ben Roethlisberger
7. Tom Brady
8. John Elway
9. Peyton Manning
10. Bart Starr

It might not be right to YOU but then again it's not like you actually WATCH him play. He is the definition of "greatness"...I'm out..
14 answers 14