Will You Take my singer vs singer poll?

Linda Ronstadt vs Carly Simon

Janis Joplin vs Joe Cocker

James Taylor vs Jim Croce

Robert Plant vs Roger Daltry

John Lennon vs Paul McCartney

Michael McDonald vs Patrick Simmons vs Tom Johnston - which Doobie singer do you prefer

Paul Rogers vs Steve Perry

Ann Wilson vs Pat Benatar

Tom Waits vs Lou Reed

Tom Petty vs Bruce Springsteen

James Hetfield vs Dave Mustaine

19 Answers

Relevance
  • 9 years ago
    Best Answer

    Some tough choices there my friend, but I will go with my initial instinct and not edit:

    Carly Simon

    Janis- too easy, no brainer

    James Taylor- for personal reasons

    Roger Daltry

    John Lennon- sorry, but McCartney had at best 20% of Lennon's talent

    McDonald

    Rodgers- he proved this when playing live with "Queen"

    Pat Benatar

    Lou Reed- I find Waits difficult. But I love Leonard Cohen, so what do I know?

    Tom Petty by the proverbial mile

    Heads or Tails? Hetfield

  • 5 years ago

    Rondstadt

    Joplin

    Taylor

    Plant

    McCartney

    Johnston

    Rogers

    Wilson

    Reed

    Springsteen

    Hetfield

  • 9 years ago

    Carly Simon

    Janis Joplin

    James Taylor

    Robert Plant

    John Lennon

    Michael McDonald

    Steve Perry

    Ann Wilson

    Tom Waits

    Tom Petty

    Dave Mustaine

  • 9 years ago

    Carly Simon > Linda Ronstadt

    James Taylor > Jim Croce

    Robert Plant > Roger Daltry

    Paul McCartney > John Lennon

    Paul Rogers > Steve Perry

    Ann Wilson > Pat Benetar

    Lou Reed > Tom Waits

    Tom Petty > Bruce Springsteen

    James Hetfield > Dave Mustaine

    And just because...

    Joey Ramone > Johnny Rotten

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    Linda Ronstadt

    Janis Joplin

    James Taylor

    Robert Plant

    John Lennon

    Michael McDonald

    Steve Perry

    Pat Benetar

    Lou Reed

    Bruce Springsteen

    James Hetfield

  • 9 years ago

    Linda Ronstadt

    Janis Joplin

    Jim Croce

    Roger Daltry

    Paul McCartney

    Tom Johnston

    Steve Perry

    Pat Benatar

    Lou Reed

    Bruce Springsteen

    -

  • 9 years ago

    Carly Simon

    Joe Cocker

    James Taylor

    Robert Plant

    Paul McCartney

    Michael McDonald

    Steve Perry

    Ann Wilson

    Lou Reed

    Tom Petty

  • 9 years ago

    OK please dont hate me for my answers :)

    Linda Ronstadt (they say I look like her and I love the song Willin) love Carly too though

    Janis Joplin she died way too soon!

    James Taylor though I did love Jim Croce I had more from James Taylor

    Not sure here for Plant vs Daltry

    This one is really hard I love them both but I am going with John Lennon he was a genius at least in my mind

    I liked them all so cannot pick just one

    Steve Perry

    Pat Benatar

    Lou Reed

    hmm tough again but I love Tom Petty sorry Bruce

    do not know the bottom two sorry

  • Paix
    Lv 4
    9 years ago

    Carly Simon

    Janis Joplin

    James Taylor

    Robert Plant

    John Lennon

    none

    not a huge fan of either but Steve Perry

    Ann Wilson

    Lou Reed

    Tom Perry

    none

  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    I sure will :)

    Linda Rondstadt

    Joe Cocker

    James Taylor

    Roger Daltrey

    John Lennon

    Tom Johnston

    Paul Rogers

    Ann Wilson

    Lou Reed

    Tom Petty

    **

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.