Anonymous
Anonymous asked in 社會與文化語言 · 1 decade ago

instead of用法

Why _______ you go swimming instead of go shopping?

A. do

B. don't

為什麼不能選A?

"你們為什麼要游泳代替購物?"

5 Answers

Rating
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    版主, 這是那裡的題目? 是學校的考題嗎?

    容筆者指出, 這道題目又是劣質命題老師的大凸槌!

    不但 A.與B.都是正解, 而且題目文法錯誤!

    先說文法錯誤: instead of後面怎能用原式go呢? 應改正為going.

    再說選項:

    Why do you go swimming instead of going shopping?

    你怎麼去游泳而不去逛街呢?

    Why don't you go swimming instead of going shopping?

    你何不去游泳而不要去逛街?

    兩句的文法與語意完全正確, 怎能用來作為單選題??

    Source(s): 英文文法
  • 1 decade ago

    instead of 擺句首世介係詞片語 instead of擺句首+ving

    instead 擺句尾是副詞

    instead of 表否定涵義,表「代替...(而~),不...(而~)」

    副詞instead表 (代替 反而 相反地)

    ex:

    Let's play video games INSTEAD OF watching TV.

    我們來打電動 不要看電視了

    INSTEAD OF cleaning the room, he went to sleep.

    他並未清理房間而去睡覺

    I should have studied, but I went to the movies INSTEAD.

    我原本該讀書但我卻看電影

    Source(s): 高中課本:)
  • 1 decade ago

    (1)先來看insead of的用法

    insread of有2個意思

    第一個就是代替的意思

    後面接:

    1.名詞

    I will give you a cup of coffee instead of tea.

    我會給您一杯咖啡,而非一杯茶

    2.名詞片語

    I will tell you how to do it instead of what to do only.

    我會告訴您怎麼做,而非叫您做什麼而已

    3.接名詞子句

    I will lend what I think you need instead of what you ask for.

    我會借您我認為您所需要的,而非您所要求的

    另一個意思是''不....而'',後面就可以接動詞了,但是要接Ving

    (2)再來看go shopping

    go+Ving表去做什麼事

    是個動詞片語

    看例句

    可能是翻譯錯誤

    要翻''你們為什麼不去游泳而要去購物呢??''

    這樣的話,(B就正確了)

    但是後面動詞要加ing

    Why don't you go swimming instead of going shopping?

  • 呆子
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    instead of going shopping.介繫詞後跟動名詞-------

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    因為 don't 是"否" 的意思

    所以這句話的意思是說

    你為什麼不以游泳代替購物呢?

    意思就是叫你 別在購物了

    如果使用do 那這句就不合邏輯了喔

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.