Well, as you can see by the 8 comments before mine, Peyton is the concensus pick, and I agree, he is the better Qb. HOWEVER. Peyton choked in the superbowl twice, and only won one because he was playing against Rex Grossman. Eli, on the other hand, went in as a huge underdog and won the game. If I was going to draft one out of college, sure I'd take Peyton, but I don't think he is as much better as everyone seems to think.