This or That Girls Names: Trendy 2009 Names vs Trendy 1909 Names?

Pick ONE name from each line. "Both" or "Neither" is not a choice. If you happen to hate both, pick the one you hate least. The Left Column are popular names of 2009, the Right Column is popular names of 1909. I pick one name from the top ten, one from the top twenty, one from the top thirty and... show more Pick ONE name from each line. "Both" or "Neither" is not a choice. If you happen to hate both, pick the one you hate least. The Left Column are popular names of 2009, the Right Column is popular names of 1909. I pick one name from the top ten, one from the top twenty, one from the top thirty and so on, so popularity should match up (For example, a #32 2009 name will go up against a name ranked 31-40 in 1909, so popularity is similar).

Madison OR Dorothy
Ashley OR Ethel
Hailey OR Catherine
Nevaeh OR Esther
Zoe OR Eva
Bella OR Laura
Faith OR Mae
Katelyn OR Lucy
Paige OR Maggie

BQ: How many 2009 names do you prefer?
BQ2: How many 1909 names do you prefer?
BQ3: In conclusion, do you prefer modern 2009 names or older 1909 names?
BQ4: What's your favorite name on this list?
BQ5: Least favorite?
66 answers 66