Sorry dear, to break gently to you like this.
God respects free will in every human. You must always bear that in mind.
God WON'T ever make him be whatever you want him to be - BECAUSE GOD RESPECT FREE WILL. God doesn't make anyone a prisoner of His divine will. That's the truth. It took me a painfully long, long time to understand God.
The handsomest man whom you fancy is entitled to be whatever he wants to be in life. For example, if he doesn't want to be Muslim, then he won't be one and God WON'T ever change this man's mind, no matter how many duas are prayed to God, no matter how long you may perpetuate your prayers.
The thing is, you CAN'T choose any man you may want, however desperate you are. God won't choose this man for you, unless this man is your soulmate divinely matched to you.
You can go on praying all the duas for as many years as you like. Eventually and painfully, you'll discover why the man won't come to you - it's all because God respects this man's free will and his freedom of choice as He does ours.
Alternatively, ask God to choose a man who He thinks is best for you.
Let God do all the choosing for you rather than imploring God to choose any particular man whom you fancy. You have to let go of your particular needs and embrace God's choices for you.
God chooses only what He thinks is only for your highest good.
If God chooses that particular man for you, then this man is meant for you and is your divinely matched soulmate.
If God chooses someone else, don't despair. Whatever God chooses is many times better than your expectations. Be glad that the man isn't going to be a wife batterer or axe murderer. No matter what you may think, don't ever refuse God's choice of man for you, if this man happens to be someone else.
All the same, do ask God to choose a man for you, a man of God's own choice for you. Let's see what happens within a few days or months, within a few years. Have patience. The man will come at God's chosen time.
Whatever rosy expectations you may have of this handsomest man in mind, he might someday shatter your illusions and break your heart big time. Be prepared for any disappointment. Meanwhile, be strong and brave.
Remember, the handsomest men on earth can lose their looks, come down with obesity, acnes, hair loss, myriad health problems, etc. Your handsomest man might become one of them: bald, fat and ugly. Then you'll fall out of love with him.
I wish you best of luck for your future happiness. Cheers.