Who thinks Reggie Jackson shouldve went in the hall as an Athletic and not a Yankee?

He started off his career as an Athletic. He played for the Athletic for 9 years compared to the Yankees with only 5. He won 3 World Series as an Athletic compared to 2 with the Yankees. He hit 254 homeruns as an Athletic compared to 144 as a Yankee. He has 6 all star appearances as a Athletic and 5 as a Yankee.... show more He started off his career as an Athletic. He played for the Athletic for 9 years compared to the Yankees with only 5. He won 3 World Series as an Athletic compared to 2 with the Yankees. He hit 254 homeruns as an Athletic compared to 144 as a Yankee. He has 6 all star appearances as a Athletic and 5 as a Yankee. Most of his career and his accomplishments were in a Athletics uniform than any other team he played for. Take away those 3 homeruns he hit in the World Series in that last game with the Yankees and he is nothing special. Do you think he shouldve went in the hall of fame wearing an Athletics cap? if he never had the choice to pick what team he wouldve went in as, would the hall of fame choose him to go in as an Athletic? After all, his plaque is a Yankee uniform. Should the cap in the plaque just go to where ever they played the longest?
Update: Why did Reggie Jackson go in as a Yankee?
8 answers 8