Muslims, if an angel comes and tells you that the Qu'ran is wrong...?

Would you believe the angel, why or why not?
Update: Deedat, Muhammad believed he met a demons who gave him revelation. We both agree this revelation ( the Quran) is not in agreement with the word of God that was available to him. Muhammad chose to believe the spirit rather than the scriptures. I ask you... if you had the same experience as the man you call... show more Deedat, Muhammad believed he met a demons who gave him revelation.
We both agree this revelation ( the Quran) is not in agreement with the word of God that was available to him.
Muhammad chose to believe the spirit rather than the scriptures.
I ask you... if you had the same experience as the man you call prophet..would you believe the spirit or the word of God?
Update 2: Seraph, Muhammad chose to follow a spirit that disagreed with the word of God available to him..why is it you would not do as your prophet?
Update 3: Curious, Doesn't Islam teach the word of God became corrupt and Muhamamd received a revelation from a spirit that was not in agreement with the written word of God available to him? Was Muhammad wrong to believe a spirit that disagreed with scriptures?
Update 4: Race 2 4giveness of Allah, I competely agree with you. Wonder why Muhammad did not do this?
Update 5: Light, So when your prophet received his revelation that disagreed with the word of God he should have known it was Satan correct?
Update 6: Good answers my Muslim friends...If a spirit disagrees with scripture he must be Satan...So why do you follow a man who followed a spirit you yourself say must have been Satan that disagreed with the scriptures?
Update 7: So why do you follow a man who would reject the word of God and believed the spirit that disagreed with the word of God? Each of you say the spirit that disagreed with the scriptures you would have known was Satan..yet you choose to follow a man who you think believed Satan over the word of God.
Update 8: Truthseeker, Jesus does not teach you to follow Islam. Jesus is the good news and the word of God according to the Quran. The good news has not changed it is the atonement and resurrection of Jesus Christ. You should learn to test a spirit with the word of God as directed by God. Those who trust any spirit they... show more Truthseeker, Jesus does not teach you to follow Islam. Jesus is the good news and the word of God according to the Quran. The good news has not changed it is the atonement and resurrection of Jesus Christ.
You should learn to test a spirit with the word of God as directed by God.
Those who trust any spirit they hear will follow the teachings of demons.
Any spirit or prophet has to be tested with the word of God and the words of the prophets.
Islam is not in agreement with the word of God spoke to Moses nor given to any of the prophets nor is in it in agreement with the teachings of Jesus Christ. So the spirit you are listening to is not Jesus Christ.
Update 9: Zena, before a man knows an angel or a prophet is sent by God he must test the spirit with the word of God and the words of the prophets. The Bible never taught to trust every spirit that claims to be from God. Obviously many false prophets made this claim. 1John 4:1 Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try... show more Zena, before a man knows an angel or a prophet is sent by God he must test the spirit with the word of God and the words of the prophets.
The Bible never taught to trust every spirit that claims to be from God.
Obviously many false prophets made this claim.

1John 4:1 Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.
Update 10: Saya, If a spirit teaches against the word of God the spirit or the prophet is not from God.. This warning is throughout God's word beginning with the books of Moses.
Which makes Muhammad a false prophet according to the word of God.
Update 11: ALLAHU, How is it you follow a man who believed a spirit that taught against the scriptures...and you say that is wrong?
Update 12: Toor, Didn't Muhammad trust a spirit that disagreed with the written word of God available to him? Are you saying that spirit was Satan?
Update 13: 4thestraightpath. As a Christian you were taught to beware of false prophets? How were you taught to identify false prophets? Was it according to the word of God? How is ti you now call yourself Muslimah? Have you found the Quran to be in agreement with the word of God? When the word of God teaches that those who... show more 4thestraightpath. As a Christian you were taught to beware of false prophets? How were you taught to identify false prophets? Was it according to the word of God?
How is ti you now call yourself Muslimah? Have you found the Quran to be in agreement with the word of God? When the word of God teaches that those who reject the Son of God is antichrist did you decide that Islam accepts the Son of God?
Update 14: fazal, Very very good point...You are absolutely correct that this antichrist will come and claim things contrary ot the word of God and he will claim to be Jesus Christ and is not Jesus Christ.
We were warned of the antichrist by the word of God..very good.
Update 15: Libbo, Let's make it a direct question just for you. When a spirit disagrees with God was it wise to trust the spirit rather than the word of God? The man you have chose to follow rejected God's word to follow a spirit that he could not know was from God. So why do you follow a man who trusted a spirit... show more Libbo, Let's make it a direct question just for you. When a spirit disagrees with God was it wise to trust the spirit rather than the word of God?
The man you have chose to follow rejected God's word to follow a spirit that he could not know was from God.
So why do you follow a man who trusted a spirit that disagreed with God?
Update 16: Somehow I think some of you are missing the point. Muhammad met with a spirit he first believed was a demon and this spirit gave him revelation that disagreed with the scriptures..now each of you say if this were you..you would have concluded this spirit was Satan and yet each of you follow the man who accepted the... show more Somehow I think some of you are missing the point. Muhammad met with a spirit he first believed was a demon and this spirit gave him revelation that disagreed with the scriptures..now each of you say if this were you..you would have concluded this spirit was Satan and yet each of you follow the man who accepted the wrod of a spirit that disagreed with the scriptures.
Update 17: Wazeer, So what of Muhammad? He chose a spirit he first believed to be a demon over the available scriptures from God.
Update 18: Is God really subject to what we believe? I believe there is a way to know God and it is through his word but also by his revelation. God can guide us in his truth, but we do not follow spirits and men that disagree with his word and all spirits and prophets should be tested with his word. So I agree with all of... show more Is God really subject to what we believe? I believe there is a way to know God and it is through his word but also by his revelation. God can guide us in his truth, but we do not follow spirits and men that disagree with his word and all spirits and prophets should be tested with his word.
So I agree with all of you that the spirit that spoke with Muhammad should have been in agreement with the word of God and we can see this spirit spoke against the scriptures which means this spirit could not be from God and even if we decide he was we had no verification from God. How did this spirit prove he was from God? Is God's word simply left to our judgment to decide? If God's word is dependent on our judgment..why do we need a written word at all? We decided what we thought was good. Seems to be a major problem to me.
Update 19: Lexi, Amen Sis, God made it clear throughout his word how to test a spirit or a prophet with his word and the words of the prophets. There is no argument for corrupt scriptures. God's word is good if not we have no hope. It would be insane if God did not care about his word..there would be know way to know the... show more Lexi, Amen Sis, God made it clear throughout his word how to test a spirit or a prophet with his word and the words of the prophets. There is no argument for corrupt scriptures. God's word is good if not we have no hope.
It would be insane if God did not care about his word..there would be know way to know the truth but by our own corrupt judgment and no point to a written word of God at all. It would all be a judgment call by imperfect sinners.
Praise be to God that he gave us his truth and gives us a way to test the prophets and the deceiving spirits.
This is an obvious flaw in the teachings of Islam that their God did not care about his own word and the only way they can know what is true is by their own limited and imperfect flesh and blood understanding.
23 answers 23