CC Sabathia or Cliff Lee:Who would you rather have?

I know the answer for Indians fan. You want them both back. But for other fans, who? C.C. Sabathia: W-136 L-81 Winning %.627 ERA-3.62 CG-13 SHO-11 SO- 1590 Cliff Lee: W-90 L-52 Winning%.634 ERA-3.97 CG-13 SHO-4 SO-900 Factors: CC has the greatest chance out of active pitchers for the 300 win... show more I know the answer for Indians fan. You want them both back. But for other fans, who?

C.C. Sabathia: W-136 L-81 Winning %.627 ERA-3.62 CG-13 SHO-11 SO- 1590

Cliff Lee: W-90 L-52 Winning%.634 ERA-3.97 CG-13 SHO-4 SO-900

Factors:
CC has the greatest chance out of active pitchers for the 300 win club

Cliff Lee has a chance of one of the highest win-loss percentage
Update: and also why
Update 2: lets talk to their end of careers. If they both retire at like, i say 42, then Lee will retire first by about 2 years. But at that time, no way they can be good as now
17 answers 17