Wai Ho asked in 社會及文化語言 · 1 decade ago

詞評When you're gone,有無錯文法等等?

This lyric of the song is about a girl and her lover, they are separate. When they together before, she does not treasure that. She always need time on her own. When she is cry, she never need her lover. But always the things are mock, when her lover not with hers together, she is alone. When her lover is gone, she always miss him. She never feel this place before. She see his clothes are lie on the floor, and have his smell. She is repent, she is repent that why she not treasure the time of she and her lover. She want to rescue this love, but it is too late.

In this lyric of the song, writer tell us a principle, happy is in front of us, but many peoples are not treasure, always disillusion at they lose the happy. The writer hope we can treasure the happy in front of us.

1 Answer

Rating
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    i think you talking about Avril's song, right?

    actually i don't think that's a wrong grammar, and Eminem has a song "When I'm gone" as well.

    as you may know that, is/am/are + past particple is a passive voice,

    for instance, the report is written by John,

    so "When you're gone" is probably a passive voice, but who actually takes that action? it may possibly means the god, all the things happen to them, or something like that.

    when you're gone, in other words, it means when you are dead as well, so it's probably not a wrong grammar i suppose.

    2009-09-17 21:50:44 補充:

    oops..i thought you talking about the name of the song, sorry about that..

    i correct it for ya.

    This lyric of the song is about a girl and her lover, they were separate. When they were together before, she did not treasure that. She always needs time on her own.

    2009-09-17 21:50:57 補充:

    When she cried, she had never needed her lover. But the things are always mock, when they broke up, she feels alone. When her lover is gone, she always misses him. She have never felt this way before.

    2009-09-17 21:51:55 補充:

    She sees his clothes are lain on the floor, and the smell of him. She repents, repenting why did not treasure the time when they were being together. She wants to rescue this love, but it is too late.

    2009-09-17 21:52:09 補充:

    In this lyric of the song, writer tells us the principle, happy is in front of us, but many people do not treasure, always waking up at the time they lose it. The writer hopes we can treasure the happiness in front of us.

    2009-09-17 21:52:26 補充:

    p.s.

    I didn't change many of your words, as many as i can keep to remain your own words, hope it helps =)

    (by the way, a lots of unexpected mistakes in this lyric review, where did you get it@@?)

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.