Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Anonymous asked in PetsDogs · 1 decade ago

Why is it almost all the pitbulls are owned by the poor?

I don't want this to turn into a discussion on how pitbulls are great if you train them right, which is probably true.

I just want to know why, if you have a pitbull, and they're more likely to attack strangers than any other dog (pit bulls, Rottweilers, Presa Canarios and their mixes are responsible for 74% of attacks that were included in the study, 68% of the attacks upon children, 82% of the attacks upon adults, 65% of the deaths, and 68% of the maimings), why would you want to run the risk of having to pay for someone's medical bills and perhaps a lawyer if they sue, IF YOU ARE POOR. Get a nice dog and avoid that money trap.

30 Answers

  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    What a load of pish

    If you believe what is written in the report you are quoting then you comment "and they're more likely to attack strangers than any other dog" is rubbish, it says "The vast majority of biting dogs (77%) belong to the victim's family or a friend" hardly strangers. Read the whole page and not just the bits that suit your argument.

    It also states "■Any individual dog may be a good, loving pet, even though its breed is considered to be potentially dangerous. A responsible owner can win the love and respect of a dog, no matter its breed. One cannot look at an individual dog, recognize its breed, and then state whether or not it is going to attack"

    When pitbulls were banned in the UK dog bite reports didn't fall but remained constant, People that don't train their pitbull properly will just move on to another breed if it is banned and it will continue with that dog. It's a people problem not a breed problem.

    Dog Whisperer Cesar Millan

    Helen Keller

    Anthony Robbins

    Actress Molly Price

    General George S. Patton

    Actor Jan Michael Vincent

    Fred Astaire

    Stephany Kramer

    President Woodrow Wilson

    Singer Pink

    Ashley Olsen

    Alicia Silverstone

    Humphrey Bogart

    Ananda Lewis

    Linda Blair

    John Steinbeck

    Fatty Arbuckle

    Malcolm - Jamal Warner

    Mary Tyler Moore

    Steve & Terri Irwin

    NY Mets' Mo Vaughn

    Author James Ellroy

    Actress Amy Jo Johnson

    Hawaiian Singer Jack Johnson

    Comedian Sinbad (David Adkins)

    Rosie Perez

    Actress Kelli Williams

    AJ McLean

    Rachel Ray

    Orlando Bloom

    Actor James Caan

    Shaquille “Shaq” O’Neal

    Judd Nelson

    Barbara Eden

    Veronica Mars

    Author Walter Scott

    Actor Ken Howard

    Singer Usher

    Actor Michael J. Fox

    Inventor Thomas Edison

    Mel Brooks

    Anne Brancroft

    Bernadette Peters

    Julian schnabel

    Jessica Alba

    John Stuart

    Jesse James

    Singer Stephan Jenkins

    Singer Madonna

    Boxer Jack Dempsey

    Actor Brad Pitt

    President Theodore Roosevelt

    Stephan Jenkins

    Athlete Tamika Dixon

    Singer Rick Springfield

    Actor Vin Diesel

    Barbra Ede

    Cassandra Creech

    Poet Sir Walter Scott

    Shannon Elizabeth

    Earl Holliman

    David Spade

    Green Bay Packers Robert Ferguson

    John Stewart

    Bill Berloni

    Roy Jones Jr.

    Serena Williams

    Justin Miller

    Cozy Coleman

    Veron Haynes

    Hugh Douglas


    Jermaine Dupri

    Richard "Rip" Hamilton

    50 Cent

    Young Buck

    Lloyd Banks

    Jordan Babineaux

    Jonathan Babineaux

    Maurice White

    Andrew Vachss

    Ira Glass

    Rosie Perez

    Kelli Williams

    Judd Nelson

    Thomas Edison

    Julian Schnabel

    Stephan Jenkins

    Jon Stewart

    Tamika Dixon

    Frankie Muniz

    Jon Stewart

    Artist Julian Schnabel

    Actor Fred Astaire

    Stephany Kramer

    Third Watch's Molly Price

    Author John Steinbeck

    Author Walter Scott

    Singer Chili

    Kristen Johnston

    Singer Kevin Federline

    Pittsburgh Steelers Linebacker Joey Porter

    Delores del Rio Actor Adam Brody

    These are just a handfull of people that I would not class as anywhere near poor that own or have owned pitbulls.


  • 1 decade ago

    I totally resent your last sentence.

    "Get a nice dog". How dare you. I do have nice dogs and they are rottweilers. In actual fact in the UK we do not have "legal" pitbulls now, although there are still lots about, but the bite statistics do not put rotties anywhere near the top of the list.

    In fact the animal that kills more humans per year is actually ...........................

    the horse.

    However I would agree that the wrong types are owning these dogs and attempting to turn them into weapons. Here in the UK the husky is now on the rise as a popular "street weapon", along with other mastiffs such as the French & bull.

    Please do not assume that all rottie owners are poor. I am not rich but I am a well respected ballet teacher, and a friend of mine is the physio for virtually all the professional dancers in London.

    What dogs does she have -- rotties.

  • 1 decade ago

    Well, you've sort of answered the question on your own. It stems from ignorance and lack of education which are directly correlated to poverty.

    Sadly there is an overabundance of pit bulls around so there fore they are easy to acquire, and often free. The first problem. No cost to get.

    Once a pit is in the possession of a less educated individual, the dog is subject to the possibility of not being handled and trained properly. Never mind their lack of resources to vaccinate the dogs and have them spayed or neutered. Which most educated people know, is a good way to prevent behavioral issues right from the start. It's amazing the role hormones play into a dogs behavior.

    Upon developing behavior problems, the owner is not in a position to invest in corrective action.

    It is an unfortunate situation that is a bit of a negative spiral of events.

    The key to eliminating poverty is increasing educational opportunities for the underprivileged. And until there is a change in how money is distributed in the education system there will still be this gap between classes of people.

    Source(s): vet industry worker
  • 1 decade ago

    There is an over abundance of the breed as well as crosses of the breed. They are easily obtained and are not really accpeted as a purebred or refined breed. I guess each to their own and often then not, too many people get them as an "Imagine thing." I personally do not like the breed, nor do I trust them and that is from experience. But it is America and for now people can take the risk. And for so many that have the breed for an imagine they really do not worry about a lawsuit. Think about their life style, I think a lawsuit is their last concern. One can not get money from someone who has nothing.

    There are a lot of good people out there that have the breed and they truly have them for the love of the breed and nothing else.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    First & foremost statistics can be manipulated & presented in such a way as to give weight to whatever end result the person presenting the information wants.

    As a percentage of the population serious dog bites/fatalities are incredibly rare, but at first glance that is not what you may be lead to believe.

    Any dog could bite, but poorly bred & genetically weak nerved/shy are the most likely to be fear biters. People who purchase purebreds then fail to train them or purchase a breed because they want a vicious beast of a dog by their side, contribute to the breeds bad reputation.

    A dog is only as dangerous as the owner allows it to be. The owner controls every aspect of their dogs enviroment including its training, where it goes & whether or not it meets humans, dogs & other animals. A responsible dog owner reads their dogs body language & ensures that their dog is always under control.

    Poor in comparison to what? Someone of modest means may be a very responsible dog owner, whereas someone with more money than sense may not invest sufficient time to train their dog.

    What is a nice dog?

    A nice dog to me is not breed specific, has solid nerves, a stable temperament & is obedience trained by a calm, firm non aggressive owner to behave in a socially acceptable manner.

  • Anonymous
    7 years ago

    Health care reform hangs in the balance that's not an exaggeration. If Democrats try to delay Brown's seating by ten days, the blowback will be fierce.

    (4) The decision was made in light of external press coverage and polling. (Coakley's latest internals have her DOWN four points in the latest daily track.)

    Attachment image
  • ?
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    The stats don't relate the number of bites/breed with number of that breed owned. I'm certain the number of pits (I use the generic term) owned is higher than the number of wheaten terriers owned, for example. That isn't included.

    Nowhere is there any stat on income vs. breed owned.

    Apparently you have some sort of horrible prejudice against low-income persons. I have been one of those persons, the 'working poor' I believe it was termed. We who don't have much money are just as wonderful people as those who have too much money.

    I've known many pits who were owned by all sorts of people. I've known many lower income people who did not own pits.

    Income has nothing to do with it.

    Ridiculous rant.

    added: Amen, Lorraine! 'Get a nice dog' ticked me off too. I've met MANY pits in our clinic, and even sick pits were sweet as they could be. They are ALL nice! And Rotts are awesome. They too, have all been nice dogs. I love Rotts.

    Source(s): RVT, specialty clinic
  • rachel
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    I honestly think all the attacks are caused directly by the poor owners. They do not take any of responsibility it takes to take care of a dog seriously. Yes, Pit Bulls were bred to be fighting dogs and it's basically what they were for, but by getting these dogs in the right hands, we can change that. But people who get these dogs are usually lower class, irresponsible people who solely want these dogs because they look tough and they're "cool." The dogs end up living in the back yard deveoping these aggressive tendencies in them. They are a powerful breed and can escape the back yard. Without the training they missed by living in the backyard, they have no socialization and of course they will lash out at people and other dogs! They don't know better! These people also do not pay to get their dogs fixed because they think "Hey, it's a pure bred Pit Bull, so of course I have to breed it!" So they breed them without the money to pay for any complications that may happen, passing them out to all of their lower class friends and earning some "easy" cash. Those puppies could be carrying some of their parents seemingly bad traits, causing this chain to just go on and on and on.

    People of higher class can pay for training for the dog and are a lot more likely to know what they could be getting into. They can pay for proper medical care and can pay to get them fixed.

    I think Pit Bulls can be amazing dogs when they are placed in the right hands. Personally, I could never handle one. I know I couldn't, so I am not even going to try because I don't want to make my dog the next statistic.

  • anne b
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Well, how odd. All the people I know with pits are not "poor".

    And bite statistics are always skewed by the media and the amount of mixed breed bites, along with all those bites that were never reported, so I would take that data and...throw it away!

  • That's stereotyping, seriously. Do you know how many people here on Y!A own bully breeds? By asking this question you pretty much just insulted them all.

    Being poor has nothing to do with your ability to have a nice, trained dog.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.