Edge is better, IMO.
Randy Orton Failed to carry RAW for two months and his PPV matches againt Batista were awful. He spent most of the time just running away and it made him look like a weak Chapion.
He always has to have Priceless next to him to help him win a match, no matter what match it is....
Randy Ortons gimmick is also, non believeable, he comes out looking like a tough bada$$, only to run away like a silly little girl.
While Edge, he cheats, yeah, because hes a heel and should get heat from the fans, but does he run away when the chances are stacked against him? No. Does he cut the same robotic promo every week? No he does not.
And plus, Edge can make some great matches and make anyone look good in the ring, while Orton, the other guy has to carry him throughout the match......
The Wings Of Love