Were Stephen and JT dumb to vote out Tyson on Survivor?

Now they eliminate the warrior allience and may find them selves down in numbers unless Sierra swings. If they kept the warrior allience Sierra would've gone home and they would've taken out Errin and Taj going to the Final 5. Some say that the members of Timbira in the group (Tyson, Coach and Debby)... show more Now they eliminate the warrior allience and may find them selves down in numbers unless Sierra swings. If they kept the warrior allience Sierra would've gone home and they would've taken out Errin and Taj going to the Final 5.

Some say that the members of Timbira in the group (Tyson, Coach and Debby) would've gone after JT or Stephen at that pt The thing is they had the idol which becomes useless after that episode

The smart move would've been to get to the Final 5 and once they get their the 3 Timbira members would've likely gone after JT (The stronger person)> The smart move would be for JT to play the idol and have him and Stephen vote out Tyson. That would've made JT the strongest person going into the last challenge
Update: I'm not talking about whether you're happy to see Tyson gone but whether it was a smart move for Stephen and JT

They lose an alliance where JT would've emerged as the strongest person going into the Final 4 if they played it right
Update 2: edit- James. God p about how Errin gave JT an idication she'd flip. You also think Sierra would because you know she wants to rub "You made your bed now LAY on it" at Coach. Plus she doesn't seem to like Errin Meanwhile she seemed friendly w/Taj at Exile and Stephen and JT haven't pissed... show more edit- James. God p about how Errin gave JT an idication she'd flip. You also think Sierra would because you know she wants to rub "You made your bed now LAY on it" at Coach. Plus she doesn't seem to like Errin

Meanwhile she seemed friendly w/Taj at Exile and Stephen and JT haven't pissed her off yet.

However it seems she may actually stay w/Coach, Debby and Errin
6 answers 6