What do you think about this here League of the United Latin American Citizens border may be illegitimate?

CASEY WIAN, CNN CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): The United States/Mexico border was established in 1848 by the Treaty of Guadeloupe Hidalgo which ended the Mexican/American war and the Gadsden Purchase in 1854.

A century and a half later the California chapter of the League of the United Latin American Citizens is questioning the very legitimacy of the order, as part of their effort to secure amnesty for illegal aliens following President Obama's recent trip to Mexico.

BARACK OBAMA, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: My country has been greatly enriched by migration from Mexico. Mexican-Americans form a critical and enduring link between our nations. And I am committed to fixing our broken immigration system.

WIAN: LULAC claims that 2008 Supreme Court decision in a Texas death penalty case involving a Mexican citizen could render the 1848 border treaty invalid because Congress failed to make the treaty binding on individual states.

So its California director says, "The government of Mexico should exercise its rights to third-party arbitration and reopen all questions of immigration including the rights of Mexican citizens in the United States and the legitimacy of the border itself."

The group says Mexicans in the United States were treated unfairly after Guadeloupe Hidalgo and should now be given legal status.

JAN TUCKER, LULAC, CALIFORNIA CHAPTER: Mexico didn't get what it bargained for in giving up its land, then why should it be bound by that border? And even if we're not going to revisit the issue of the border per se, shouldn't Mexico have a right to a third party examination?

WIAN: California LULAC suggests Canada, Brazil, Great Britain or France could help renegotiate the border treaty.

LULAC's national office did not respond to requests for comment on its California chapter statement which also criticized the Obama administration's appointment of Allen Bornstein as border czar. He's a former San Diego U.S. attorney credited with cracking down on illegal immigration during the 1990s.


WIAN: We spoke with Santa Clara University law professor David Sloss who's written extensively on the Medellin versus Texas Supreme Court decision. He called LULAC's claim that the border is illegitimate, quote, "pretty absurd."

However, Sloss says there is the small possibility that a small number of descendants of Mexicans living in the southwest in 1848 could have a claim to U.S. citizenship, Lou.

DOBBS: All right. And one would hope that they are already citizens.

We appreciate it. Thank you, Casey. Another bizarre part of what is often a very messy issue, illegal immigration, border security. You would think it should be so straightforward, wouldn't you?


5 Answers

  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Oh no, there are no groups working for reconquista of that land! There's your proof. They are working to take the land by any means necessary... flooding it with illegals, stealing identities to claim they work and pay taxes, etc... We need to get tough with these groups, illegal alien invaders and do something now.... or who knows what the future holds. The leaders of this country are slowing giving it away along with our rights. One day there will be a tipping point, will we citizens be ready to take control?

  • 1 decade ago

    If they are not bound by the border, then how would the people be called US citizens and given US rights under the laws?

    I believe it is a frivilous claim for trying to give them amnesty. If in fact the border is inaccurate, then quit stealing my labor to give them foodstamps,welfare, healtcare, etc....

    I can tell you, that if there is a re-ruling on the border, my state will not be bound to give them any of its services.

    And just how is our country greatly enriched by their migration? Can we get an example or two instead of Obama just shooting off at the mouth.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    LULAC is a bunch of crazies who are mostly ignored by thinking Americans.

    I would not worry too much about their mad ramblings.

    When Congress and the President start saying things like this..then we will have to defend ourselves from our own government.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Mexico lost the war, it also lost ANY right to challenge where WE decided the border was to be located. As the ancient saying goes, To the Victor goes the spoils.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Wow, those history re-writing marxists must be desperate!

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.