Why can't American Idol surprise us like Susan Boyle on this week's Britain's Got Talent?
She's all over the US news, and already 4M views on YouTube:
Clearly, Susan Boyle is going to win BGT 2009 for sure. Wow! What a shocker, and what a talent!
- DenaLv 71 decade agoFavorite Answer
Because Susan Boyle is in a "league of her own". No one can touch her. She takes your breath away when she sings.
- IMOLv 61 decade ago
Well, Susan Boyle would never win American Idol...American Idol is more for pop singers...modern on the radio...not musical theater or opera.
She's good, but not suited for American Idol.
- 1 decade ago
Because nothing based in Hollywood would allow a woman built like her near the stage, regardless of vocal quality. She's too old for Hollywood, too plain, too built like a normal human being. The key term in American Idol that explains why is "American."