do you agree from this discussion that hispanics will take of america and the language?
do you agree with this discussion that hispanics will take over the language of america to spanish?
- PhilLv 71 decade agoFavorite Answer
It would be good to look at our past for a similar situation:
Benjamin Franklin, in his 1751 pamphlet Observations Concerning the Increase of Mankind, wrote:
"Why should the ... [Germans] be suffered to swarm into our Settlements, and by herding together establish their Language and Manners to the Exclusion of ours? Why should Pennsylvania, founded by the English, become a Colony of Aliens, who will shortly be so numerous as to Germanize us instead of our Anglifying them, and will never adopt our Languages or Customs, any more than they can acquire our Complexion."
...Pennsylvania was at this time about 33% German immigrants....
Last time I was in Pennsylvania they spoke English. Of course, I do too, but then I'm a descendent of those folks he was talking about.
1. Ben was wrong, the Germans learned English.
2. Every other immigrant group has learned. Most of them the children of the immigrants, immigrants themselves tend to be poor and older and don't learn the language, or don't learn it well, But their children do.
3. EVERY immigrant group that has come to America has done it, Chinese, Japanese, Mexican, Norwegian, German, Italian...
4. THe immigrant bashers are wrong, English language and American culture will thrive on new immigrants who will in a generation be as completely American as I am.
- Don CamiloLv 51 decade ago
The language of most of america is spanish
- 1 decade ago
Well, it makes sense. Two thousand years ago Spanish was Latin, the most advanced language in the West. Two thousand years ago the Angles, Saxons and Jutes were still grunting and running after bears, living in caves.
Since Spanish is a much more advanced, civilized, sophisticated language, it follows that it will allow for better communication in an integrated world.
- lemboLv 44 years ago
nicely, i'm Hispanic and that i will permit you recognize that regrettably, there's a brilliant type of our race that purely waste time in this u . s . a .. I do think of that does who prefer to paintings for their kin ought to come here and stay. a number of them care lots approximately their kin that they even paintings for minimum salary. yet I do think of that people who come to thieve, kill, etc must be back to the place they belong asap.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- JoeBobLv 51 decade ago
funny the gov. will not make english the Official language in the states
- Anonymous1 decade ago
first, hispanics are Americans!!!!!! Why then do many hispanics claim to be Mexican American ?With Obama taking our freedoms away I suspect this will happen .Obama is always on Tv and is always talking like he is still running for office
- AlefernyLv 51 decade ago
a couple of points....
first, hispanics are Americans!!!!!!
second, language can't be controlled by laws..... language is spoken by the people, on the streets, in homes, and in communities not what linguists believe it is or what politicians make "official"
third, xenophobia is what makes insecure people believe that brown people will take over "white" America!!!!!
- Anonymous1 decade ago
No. Stop listening to Pat Buchanan.
- Turd FergusonLv 41 decade ago
No Habla espanol and never will, I have no need for that filthy language or the racist people that call that their native language.
- Mendi8aLv 51 decade ago
thats just silly