Anonymous asked in Entertainment & MusicMusicRock and Pop · 1 decade ago

Good Cover/Bad Cover Which Is it?

Original: Fire - The Crazy World Of Arthur Brown

Youtube thumbnail

Cover: Fire - Prodigy

Youtube thumbnail

Original: The Mexican - Babe Ruth

Youtube thumbnail

Cover: The Mexican: Helloween

Youtube thumbnail

Original: Warning - The Aynsley Dunbar Retaliation

Youtube thumbnail

Cover: Warning - Black Sabbath

A: What do you think of these covers?

B: Care to try Your had at it?


B Means

Would You like to post some Cover comparisons of Your own? Feel free too.

Update 2:


It would probably interesting to hear some People here cover them, lol. Lotta musicians here.

Update 3:

I know I say this a lot (lulzzzzz)

But, Thanks Dude!

(I love a Pun)

4 Answers

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Well... I really like the original of "Fire", but the cover is great too... Can I'm going to go undecided on this one :P

    I don't really like the original of "The Mexican"... The cover... I can't get over how cheesy Helloween can be, haha! I guess I'll pick the Helloween version, but neither really tickled my pickle.

    The Black Sabbath version of "Warning" is great! I've heard it many times! I've never heard the original though... I really like it!! It's the kind of classic rock I enjoy!! I think I'll go with the original!!

    I'll do part B in a few, youtube stopped working for some reason =/

    Edit-- Okay! Part B!!

    Original: "Burn In Hell" by Twisted Sister

    Youtube thumbnail

    Cover: "Burn In Hell" by Dimmu Borgir

    Youtube thumbnail


    Original: “Rock Me Amadeus” by Falco

    Youtube thumbnail


    Cover: “Rock Me Amadeus” by Sturmgeist

    Youtube thumbnail

  • Me
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago


    1. The Crazy World of Arthur Brown - I liked this song a lot, it was quirky. Haha.

    2. The Prodigy - Hm I liked this one as well, but differently. On an everyday listen I think this one is easier for me to listen to, but the original was really great.

    "The Mexican"

    1. Babe Ruth - Didn't really care for this one. Neat yell at 0:50 though.

    2. Helloween - Well it's not something I'd instantly gravitate to but it's more easily listenable for me. I think the original is better though....I think....well....this is hard. xD


    1. The Aynsley Dunbar Retaliation - Very nice, I like it.

    2. Black Sabbath - Okay well all I was getting was the 30 second preview, even after signing in, so I had to use another link.

    I really like this cover. I mean I liked the original but I like this cover just as much. I can't decide which one I like more....I'll go with the cover.

    Okay I'll list some covers then. :P

    "Victoria" - original by The Kinks (1969)

    Youtube thumbnail

    "Victoria" - cover by The Fall (1988)

    Youtube thumbnail

    "Colorblind" - original by Counting Crows (1999)

    Youtube thumbnail

    "Colorblind" - cover by Natalie Walker (2006)

    Youtube thumbnail

    "Jolene" - original by Dolly Parton (1973)

    "Jolene" - cover by QueenAdreena (2007)

  • Ace
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago


    I liked the original version better than the cover done by Prodigy

    The Mexican

    I do like both of versions of the song but i think the Helloween one was alot better


    I do like both versions of the song but i think the Black Sabbath was alot better

  • Dude
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    Fire-Original- I thought The cover was way too wierd and the original was really good

    The Mexican-Cover- Helloween is a great band and that cover rocked.

    Warning-Cover- One of my favorite Sabbath songs.

    Id find some covers but youtube's not working for some reason.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.