Anonymous
Anonymous asked in News & EventsCurrent Events · 1 decade ago

Do you think Israel is justified for all its innocent killings?

I know they must do what has to be done to defend their country from rockets but 1200 killed in gaza, 800 are innocent civilians.

Are they just killing innocents so they can show hamas who is the boss?

No wonder Israel is charged of war crimes..

whats everyone's else's opinion

Update:

akmal- I Think they did fight with hezballah but its not solving anything. Israel is 450x stronger then hamas, it will just add more civilian deaths

16 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Best Answer

    No, its not justified at all.

    ------------------------

    Edit:

    quote from "Private":

    ------------------------

    Probably the poster is not aware that Israel routinely text messages all the mobile phones in target areas of Gaza to warn of impending attacks.

    This is highly unusual as it obviously loses the element of surprise and thus reducing the effectiveness of the attacks.

    During the incursion into Gaza, Israeli forces were still under attack and forced to return fire. The fact that civilians were still present in the combat zone tells us much more about the recklessness of Hamas than it does about Israel.

    Israel did not intentionally kill any civilians and there is no evidence whatsoever to suggest that it did.

    Hamas do intentionally kill civilians and there is ample evidence.

    Furthermore, if the Arabs want to prevent more bloodshed then they should refrain from firing rockets into Israel, Something that they have continued since the ceasefire.

    --------------------------

    First: you said: “Probably the poster is not aware that Israel routinely text messages all the mobile phones in target areas of Gaza to warn of impending attacks…”

    This is just another lie which you and other israelites try to abreact it by massive propaganda.

    You assert that israel routinely text messages all the mobile phones in target areas of Gaza.

    When civilians in Gaza die because they have no food, medicine and fuel, how could they have mobile phones? Note that Gaza where in massive black out during the war and even if we accept your lies about mobile phones, I wonder how Palestinians in Gaza were able to keep their mobile phones charged when there were black out in Gaza for more than 22 days? By the way, how did israel found Palestinians mobile numbers?

    It is interesting that israel first asserted that they dropped text messages over target areas and now you assert that israel routinely text messages all the mobile phones in target areas of Gaza!

    maybe this is how they send message:

    http://www.bubbleshare.com/album/48388/overview

    Second: you said: “Israel did not intentionally kill any civilians and there is no evidence whatsoever to suggest that it did.”

    Now I like to ask a question: why israelite snipers assassinated Palestinian kids and shoot them in their chest, use kids as human shield and burned kids with white phosphorus Bombs (which is an unauthorized weapon)?

    WARNING:

    these links contain harsh pics.

    ---------------------

    http://www.aljazeera.net/mritems/images/2009/1/7/1...

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cktOG0I3xgo

    Youtube thumbnail

    http://sites.google.com/site/falastinel7ora/israel...

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vq-b_40IKfs

    Youtube thumbnail

    Third: you said: “Furthermore, if the Arabs want to prevent more bloodshed then they should refrain from firing rockets into Israel, Something that they have continued since the ceasefire.”

    When israel occupied Palestine by stupid reasons and support of US and UK, starve Palestinians and kill them every day by different fake excuses, you cant expect Palestinians to remain silent and just watch them.

    http://sites.google.com/site/falastinel7ora/it-s-n...

    http://israelingaza.wordpress.com/2009/01/06/this-...

    http://sites.google.com/site/falastinel7ora/israel...

    http://sites.google.com/site/falastinel7ora/more-o...

    http://sites.google.com/site/falastinel7ora/massac...

  • 3 years ago

    Capital punishment is a mundane penalty for crime no longer a spiritual one. It isn’t the animal kingdom of faiths that exercising this penalty whether a number of them have it written into their faith. cutting-edge states have a spirit and character of their very own which will have been stimulated by employing faith yet are for the main section separate entities now. Why capital punishment remains supported is yet another concern. From a financial attitude criminals that have dedicated atrocities like the Oklahoma city bombing could be extra value-effective to execute than feed in detention center for existence however the concern is clouded by employing the legal gadget and such executions often might ensue long after the loss of life of the inmate by employing organic reasons because of the attraction technique. Timothy McVey notwithstanding refused all appeals, if purely all criminals could be as conscientious to society yet whether they are the state often forces the attraction whether the guy has no remorseful approximately. no longer something in the international concerns in the long-term so human beings like me could have adequate money to be detached to a extensive degree. I for one think of judging others is incorrect, and by employing that thinking much less of them as a individual is judgment, as for action and outcomes notwithstanding I prefer to contemplate that component to the gadget to be mechanical, like a math concern. in case you devote atrocity and that i’m on the jury i'm able to locate you in charge together as nonetheless worrying deeply for you, each and every from time to time in uncommon circumstances even sympathizing, yet punishment isn’t comparable to identifying somebody is an animal or under contempt. Punishment is punishment and societies would desire to do what’s mandatory to maintain order.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Probably the poster is not aware that Israel routinely text messages all the mobile phones in target areas of Gaza to warn of impending attacks.

    This is highly unusual as it obviously loses the element of surprise and thus reducing the effectiveness of the attacks.

    During the incursion into Gaza,Israeli forces were still under attack and forced to return fire.The fact that civilians were still present in the combat zone tells us much more about the recklessness of Hamas than it does about Israel.

    Israel did not intentionally kill any civilians and there is no evidence whatsoever to suggest that it did.

    Hamas do intentionally kill civilians and there is ample evidence.

    Furthermore,if the arabs want to prevent more bloodhsed then they should refrain from firing rockets into Israel,Something that they have continued since the ceasefire.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    to an extent, yes, because they had no altnernative option

    but obviously killing innocent people can never be fully justified

    your facts can, of course be corrected

    more than 50% of your so-called innocent were Hamas terrorist officials, and of the remaining 600 or so they were used by Hamas as human shields. youve heard it all before, im sure, but apparantly chosen to ignore it

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Bix
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    The death of innocent people is always unjust.

    However, I don't know of any war in which only the "bad guys" were killed, not even those wars approved by the international community, such as the 1st Gulf War and the Kosovo War.

    That leads to the fact that war is actually always unjust.

    The reason for the injustice of so many deaths in Gaza is Hamas and Hamas alone.

  • 1 decade ago

    What's worse? Killing innocent civilians or firing rockets knowing innocent civilians will be killed in retaliation, and then complaining about those civilian deaths. Besides, this happens all across the world every day but you never hear about it, I'm tired of seeing it published. Maybe if it wasn't reported, it would just magically go away, like Darfur. Yay!!1

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    our army drops leaflets, calls cell phones, and sends text messages before we attack an area to reduce civilian casualties. they then go and stand on the roofs of the house (always a Hamas members house, usually high ranking) to shield the house from being attacked. they know that the IDF officers will cancel an attack if there are civilians around and they use this to their advantage. its called human shields. and just so you know, most of those killed were hamas members. and many of the civilians were killed by hamas!

    and people yell at us for attacking schools...but they rig the schools and shoot at us from the schools. then video tape it so they can say we are monsters and love to kill children. are we supposed to stand there and let them shoot us because they are in a school? i think not

    http://hamas-tactics.blogspot.com/

    here you can see the true face of hamas.

    Source(s): Israeli
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Here is a summery of the story:

    Gaza is part of Palestine.

    Palestine was under the british occupation after 1st world war .In 1948 the british army delivered part of Palestine and most of british weapons hand to hand to jewish troops ( while any Palestinian reported to has a knife or small gun may be hanged by the british army) . Jewish troops built a terrorist organization called israel , then israeli troops occupied the rest of Palestine in 1967.Since that time any one who says a word or makes any action regarding freedom of Palestine will be arrested or killed .other Palestinians became refugees in Jordan, Syria, Lebanon,... . 1n 1993 Arafat & Abbas make a peace agreement with Israel without taking any action towards implementing any item of this agreement. HAMAS is an Islamic party who get majority of the votes in Palestinian 2006 elections, its objectives to liberate Palestine from israeli occupation .But Abbas party supported by USA and israel tried to get red of Hamas party Islamic power .Hamas has people support in Gaza succeeded in minimizing Abbas party influence in Gaza and get full power there since June 2007.Now Israel trying to get rid of Hamas but by killing children and women and destroying the infrastructure in Gaza using phosphorus mortars and chemical weapons .

    UK Is the father of Israel, USA is the mother, Europe countries are the boy friends ...

    NOW >>>

    >>> It's agreed upon that the land owners " FREEDOM FIGHTERS -HAMAS " are staying in their country to protect their people ,and. the " INVADERS - ISRAELI COWARD LEADERS AND SOLDERS " should be out , and trialed for their crimes in GAZA . <<<

  • 1 decade ago

    spooky

    Don't you think your false accusations and assertions are similar to Mr. Adolph Hitler's old trick?

  • 1 decade ago

    Do you think who is the judge? Who to justify to whom?

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.