Club Soda vs. Seltzer vs. Sparkling Water?

What is the difference between these clear bubbly beverages? Can they be used interchangeably in a beverage recipe?

4 Answers

  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Sparkling Water and "Seltzer" are more or less the same thing, and can be used interchangeably. Originally Seltzer was a german brand of sparkling water, but has now become a "generic trademark" (like Kleenex meaning tissue, or hoover meaning vacuum cleaner) to mean sparkling water, and has, to some extent developed a new, separate meaning.

    Today, If there is a difference at all, it would normally be that seltzer is fresh water "charged" with a CO2 siphon in a "Seltzer bottle" (see the included link) where "sparkling water" (aka carbonated water, fizzy water etc) is sold, already carbonated in a bottle, like coke or lemonade. Up market bars and restaurants will usually serve "seltzer", because it is slightly fresher, doesn't pick up the plastic bottle taste some people claim to be able to taste and doesn't get "flat" over time (because it has been "charged" with CO2 there and then) however, in reality, the difference is almost non-existent.

    Club soda or soda water is, normally, a slightly different chemical makeup, in that it often has added salt, Sodium (or potassium) bicarbonate, or sodium (or potassium) citrate to give it that slightly salty, slightly acidic taste. A club soda has more taste to it than carbonated water, and has a feel in your mouth, and on your teeth that you should detect, and in alcoholic drinks and cocktails can make a slight difference, though again, not enough to warrant really worrying about in most cases.

    The one thing that should not be interchanged with the above three (which you didn't ask about, but is worth mentioning) is tonic water. Tonic water has added quinine, and is a bitter, carbonated drink, often with sugar or artificial sweeteners and other ingredients.

    If you are looking to recreate a favorite drink from recipe It should not be used as an alternative to carbonated water, as it will give it's distinctly bitter flavor to the drink, and significantly alter the taste and sometimes even render a cocktail nearly undrinkable due to it's bitterness.

    That is not to say tonic water can not be used in your drink recipes, even instead of carbonated water, but it will not produce the same drink you were expecting, sometimes the results will be improved, sometimes not good at all, often just with added bitterness (which you may or may not like). But it's definitely not "interchangeable" in recreating drinks.

  • 3 years ago

    Seltzer Vs Club Soda

  • 1 decade ago

    They're probably okay to substitute for one another in a recipe. I think seltzer has a little more of a mineral taste than club soda. Sparkling water is, I think, very similar to club soda and may even be the same thing.

  • Linda
    Lv 4
    4 years ago

    For the best answers, search on this site

    Carbonated water - Seltzer water, ie they are both just water with carbon dioxide dissolved in them. Club soda can sometimes have vanilla flavour added, but at least in the UK it will be labelled "cream soda". None are good for you to drik a lot of, as the dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid which eats your tooth enamel away.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.