Merlin (BBC 1 TV series on saturday)?
Just wondering how is Morgana related to Uther? After watching yesterday i am now very confused. Who is she really and what does it mean by the kings ward?
But what does it mean by she is Uthers 'ward'?
Durza is there no series 2 ? :O
- JallanLv 71 decade agoBest Answer
In the medieval Arthurian legends, Morgaine la Fay is not the woman who tricked Merlin and imprisoned him. There is no cave of ice. In one version (“The Prophecies of Merlin”), Merlin was imprisoned by her in a cave where his spirit could afterwards be found. In another version (“The Post-Vulgate Merlin”, summarized in Malory's “Le Morte d’Arthur”) Merlin was imprisoned in a tomb which was part of an artificial house built under the the ground, where Merlin died. in yet another version ("The Vulgate Merlin”), Merlin was imprisoned in an invisible tower and seemingly does not die. The woman responsible is the Lady of the Lake, not Morgaine la Fay who is an entirely different person.
Morgaine was not the mother of Mordred in any extant medieval text. The mother of Mordred is another half-sister of Arthur sometimes named Morcades or Orcades or Norcades or Sangive or Margause or Belicent. She is sometimes Arthur's full sister named Anna. She is the mother of Gawain by her husband Lot and mother of Mordred also. In earlier stories Lot is also Mordred’s father, but in the later cyclic prose romances Arthur is Mordred's father.
The idea that Morgaine is Mordred’s father is pure invention by some modern novelists. Also, in medieval romances Mordred is never known as the “Black Knight”.
In Robert de Boron’s medieval work “Merlin’', Morgaine is said, in a discussion of the daughters of the Duke of Tintagel and Ygraine, to have been begotten “en baste”, that is begotten in bastardy, begotten as a bastard. It is not said whether this means that she is an illegitimate daughter of the Duke of Tintagel or an illegitimate daughter of Ygraine, but since earlier Ygraine is praised as being very loyal to her husband, it is more likely that Morgaine is the Duke of Tintagel’s bastard daughter. Also, a casual mention of a bastard daughter would, taking into accounts medieval customs, be far more likely in referring to the daughter of a man than to the daughter of a woman. As Arthur is begotten on Ygraine by Uther Pendragon, Morgaine would therefore be his step-sister, not half-sister.
But in the “Prose Lancelot”, Morgaine is said to be the daughter of the Duke of Tintagel by Ygraine, and thus Arthur's half sister.
In some other accounts Morgaine is not Arthur’s sister at all, and is shown to be active in long before the beginning of Arthur’s reign. In the “Perceforest” for example, she appears in Britain long before the coming of Joseph of Arimathea to Britain. In the romance “Huon of Bourdeau”, the fairy king Auberon is son of the famous Julius Caesar of Rome by Morgaine la Fay. In Wolfram von Eschenbach’s “Parzival”, Arthur lineage is traced back to a knight named Mazadan whom a Fay named Terredelaschoye had taken to the magic land of Faymurgan. Terrdelaschoye seems to be Wolfram’s rendering of French “terre de la joye” meaning “land of the joy”, and it is possible that he has confused the named of the fay with the name of her kingdom, that is, in Wolfraim’s source the fay was named Faymurgan (Morgaine la Fay) and her land was the land of the joy. But it might also be that Wolfram’s source mentioned an unnamed Fay of the Land of the Joy who took Mazadan to the country of Morgaine la Fay.
One gets tired of those who want to explain the true medieval account of some feature in Arthurian tales, but who don’t know it themselves, and so present either modern inventions or even their own inventions.
But, generally speaking, the BBC series has very little relation to any medieval tales. Just as the writings of many modern authors, including Bernard Cornwall, have almost nothing to do with medieval tales, quite rightly, since they are trying in part to write about what might have happened historically centuries before the medieval tales. But mostly they are writing novels, intended to entertain, and they are making most of it up, because we don’t have any texts about Arthur that are generally agreed to be historical.
Nor is it generally agreed that Arthur was a “tribal leader”.
The BBC series is just as much an invention as the medieval tales and most modern novels, save that it follows medieval traditions even less than most of them. No reason it shouldn’t.
- 1 decade ago
Morgana isn't related to Uther -- being his ward means she's under his legal protection and guardianship, as her father asked Uther to look after her.
Just saw "Something for the Weekend" with guests Bradley James and Colin Morgan -- they said that the final decision on a second series hadn't been made, but with the high viewership numbers things were looking good.
- SpacephantomLv 71 decade ago
In the proper Arthurian legends Morgana Le Fay was the witch who enchanted Merlin into telling her all his secrets, before betraying him and trapping him in a cave of ice. She was also the mother of Mordred who became the "Black Knight". He killed King Arthur and died himself in the process at the battle of Camlann.
Morgana's origins in the Arthurian legends are never clear, but in some of the stories she is portrayed as Arthur's half sister.
The TV series doesn't follow the Arthurian legends very closely, and the characters, settings, e.t.c are quite different. In the series Morgana seems to be the orphaned daughter of a noble family who has been taken under the protection of King Uther, who treats her to all intents and purposes like his own daughter. Whether she will turn to "the dark side" and become more like the Morgana of legend as the series progresses remains to be seen.
- 1 decade ago
I was wondering that the other day, but since last nights programme i realized that she isn't related to Uther its just that he promised Morgana's father he would look after her.
By the way there is only a few episodes of Merlin left
I ♥ Merlin and don't want it to end
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
that is the only thing that bugs me about this series, it was never properly explained. as i far as i interpreted it, uther and her father were friends and when he died he asked uther to look after her.
when they make a new series of anything they see how it takes off and what the viewing figures are before they decide on a second series. the viewing figures have been very good so i would reckon that there definitely will be a second series.
- BoudiccaLv 51 decade ago
Come on folk - it's only a story so I reckon the BBC can do what they like(even making Guinevere a servant to Morganna as opposed to a queen) and in no way will it interfere with the 'historical' It has generally been agreed that there was a man called Arthur, but he was a tribal leader. If you want a more reputable version of Arthur, I recommend that you read the novels by Bernard Cornwall -
The Winter King.
Enemy of God
- Anonymous1 decade ago
she is Uther's ward so she isn't related to him. He made a promise to her father that he would look after her when he died and he is!
- Anonymous1 decade ago
He promised her father he would look after her when he died, so he is her guardian and she is his ward