Anonymous asked in Business & FinancePersonal Finance · 1 decade ago

Is it better to have thousands dollars of debt in student loans or on a credit card?

I accepted a greater amount of a loan that I actually needed for school to pay off my credit card balance which was near the limit. Was that a smart thing to do? or not?


It was the Stafford loan if that makes a difference.

7 Answers

  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Yes. It was a smart thing to do. The rates are lower on your consolidated student loan and you will pay it off methodically over time.

    However, If you go charge up your credit card again, then you will undo all the benefits and make things worse. The really smart thing to do is as follows: Now that you don't have any credit card payments, you could start saving. First maximize your contribution to your company sponsored 401 K plan. That will be a good start. If you still have surplus cash each month, then you could consider opening a Roth IRA account.

    The reason I am saying this is that, young people hear so much about credit cards, but very little about saving and investing for the long term. Debt as such is not bad if it is used wisely and managed carefully.

  • 5 years ago

    1. don't chase your losses by gambling again. 2. figure out a budget of what you can afford to start paying back...then decide on what you are paying the highest interest too and start with could also start with the debts that have gone to collections most recently. I am not sure if you are in the states, but in Canada things become non-collectible after 6-7 years (depending on the province). 3. don't worry about student loans yet, because they are not in repayment yet, they are considered good debt (if there is such a thing). 4. a creditor is always going to tell you the offered payments are not good enough, but they can't get blood from a stone, so it's "this or nothing" right. 5. lastly there could be settlement offers or renegotiate interest rates to help reduce the debt increasing on a monthly basis 6. i think that because you gambled yourself into debt, you have to repay these debts.... how will getting off without penalty ever lead you away from your problem? If there is no repercussion, what would stop you from gambling again?

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    In some ways yes- you paid off a high interest credit card debt with a lower interest rate loan.

    The downside is on your tax filing. You can itemize and deduct your student loan interest on our taxes (which makes sense if your itemized $$ amt is more than the standardized limit). However, the only catch (you may need to check this) is that you should have used your entire student loan amt towards your tuituion, boks etc.

    consult with a tax advisor...

  • 1 decade ago

    if you destroyed the credit card it was probably smart. If

    you are just going to run up more debt - it could lead to disaster.

    Credit cards usually have an outrageous interest rate.

    Most of the problem the country is having now is due to

    excessive debt by individuals and our governments.

    On your blackboard, write 5000 times, "debt is not good".

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • AJ
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    depends on what interest rate you got for your loan and what was the interest rate on the credit card. Even is stafford was less, unless you make more that the minimum payment on the loans, you may still pay more on interest in the long run.

  • 1 decade ago

    Debt is Debt. It is better to have NO debt. That said, in a worst case scenario, credit cards can be discharged in bankruptcy. Stafford loans can't.

  • 1 decade ago

    It's much better to have educational debt than credit cards!

    Trust me! I know...

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.